Editore"s Note
Tilting at Windmills

Email Newsletter icon, E-mail Newsletter icon, Email List icon, E-mail List icon Sign up for Free News & Updates

March 6, 2005
By: Kevin Drum

RED STATE, BLUE STATE....Julie Saltman links to this David Brooksian rumination from Phoebe on blue staters visiting a red state:

As a Blue-Stater in a Red State (or an urbanite in a rural area) there's really no acceptable reaction to your new surroundings. Either you sneer and note the lack of Vietnamese restaurants/museums/sample sales, and you're an elitist ("What, corn dogs again?"), or you bubble over with David Brooksian enthusiasm for wholesome exurbia, in which case you're seen as smug and patronizing, or as pro-rural only to make a political point ("Mmm, corn dogs!"). A rural person visiting a city can act either awed or horrified, and either reaction is generally considered to be understandable. So what's a stranded-feeling, smile-forcing Blue American to do?

I have to confess I don't get this the same way I don't really get it when Brooks does his schtick either. I was born and raised in suburban California, so I'm pretty thoroughly blue, but I've also visited red states plenty of times on both business and pleasure and it's never seemed like that big a deal.

Lots of churches? Yeah, I guess so, although we build ours a lot bigger here in Orange County. I just drive by them. Quieter? Definitely. Restaurants? About the same, really. There are regional differences, of course, though with the growth of chains even regional differences aren't that dramatic anymore. Accents? Yeah, but I've never had any trouble understanding anyone. More Wal-Marts? Sure, but I've got two CostCos and several K-Marts within ten miles of my house. The difference isn't that noticable.

There's no question that if you get into serious conversation in small towns you'll find some bedrock differences pretty quickly: they really are more religious and more conservative on average. But we're only talking about visiting here, and on my visits I've never found red staters to be any pushier about this stuff than anyone else. What's more, while every place has its share of loons, when you stick to average people and normal staples of conversation (TV shows, the weather, good places to eat, how business is doing, etc.) there's not that much difference. My impression is that small town residents tend to be a bit less rich and bit more friendly than city dwellers, and it's true that they don't have many opera houses, but aside from that the differences don't surface all that strongly until the first Tuesday after the first Monday every four years.

So....just act normal. That's what I always do, and it seems to work fine. If that doesn't work, pretend you're in France and think of everything as charming. That works well too.

Kevin Drum 8:45 PM Permalink | Trackbacks

Bookmark and Share
 
Comments




 

 

Read Jonathan Rowe remembrance and articles
Email Newsletter icon, E-mail Newsletter icon, Email List icon, E-mail List icon Sign up for Free News & Updates

Advertise in WM



buy from Amazon and
support the Monthly