Editore"s Note
Tilting at Windmills

Email Newsletter icon, E-mail Newsletter icon, Email List icon, E-mail List icon Sign up for Free News & Updates

October 14, 2005
By: Jacob Hacker and Paul Pierson

Waiting for the Pendulum to Swing....We want to first thank Kevin for giving us access to this terrific forum. We emerge with some good new ideas, a great deal of helpful feedback, and a huge amount of new respect (and we already had a lot) for the efforts of serious bloggers.

The two objections Kevin raisedthe GOP never moved that far right, and anyway, things are swinging backare helpful challenges. We responded to the first yesterday (and got a lot of help from those who commented on Kevins post). Just to repeat one key point: Simply listing the labels of the GOPs big domestic initiatives hugely distorts the true content of their activities. Indeed, as we emphasize in the book, this distortion is a crucial component of the GOPs larger attempt to cloak immoderate policies in moderate garb.

Kevins second objection is of even greater interest at the moment. Arent the Republicans cracking up? Isnt the pendulum swinging back?

Its Friday afternoon, so well do this in bullet point style:

  • It is essential to recognize that Bushs fate and the GOPs are not identical. The heart of GOP power rests in Congress.

  • Polls this far ahead of an election tell us something, but confidence that the Republican Congressional majority is on the ropes is premature. As Chris Bowers noted yesterday at MYDD, generic Congress polls from the summer of 2004that is, far closer to the electionshowed Democrats about nine points ahead of Republicans. Anybody remember how many GOP incumbents lost?

  • Given the deplorable performance of this government, its extreme initiatives, and the supposed dangers of an off-year, second-term election for flagging presidents' parties, it speaks volumes that we even have to discuss whether Democrats can pick up just fifteen seats in 2006. As we have argued, that such a small shift by historical standards represents such a big mountain reflects the GOPs dramatic institutional and organizational advantages.

  • From our perspective, a critical thing to watch will be whether the Congressional GOP can restrain centrifugal tendencies that are currently on display. As observers, we need to distinguish between divisions that are largely staged for public consumption (to placate some audience) and those that truly undercut the GOPs impressive capacity to coordinate political action. Staged activity occurs all the time, as Matthew Yglesias recently documented in an American Prospect article on GOP moderates appropriately titled The Fraud Caucus. (One Democratic member of Congress complained that a moderate Republican is someone who throws a ten foot rope to a man drowning twenty feet off shore.") And, ironically, staged independence reinforces GOP control rather than undercutting it. Actual splintering would represent a truly important change in the political climate.

  • The focus of our book is on where the GOPs organizational and institutional advantages came from and how they are exploited to pursue extreme goals and protect incumbents. We dont focus on what agenda Democrats should present. In fact, we largely agree with Jon Chaits excellent piece this summer, The Case Against New Ideas," that the importance of the specific ideas, or even their tone, tends to be exaggerated. We should make clear that we do think ideas matter (thanks, "cmdicely," for the call for clarification), particularly for governance, and indeed one of us has been arguing for making economic security a key Democratic theme for a while. Still, the crucial challenge for the Democrats over the next year is to work in as unified a fashion as possible. It was the creation of that unity, after all, that was Gingrichs greatest contribution to the GOPs successin 1994 and since.

As we said, weve benefited enormously from this forum, and were grateful to Kevin for letting us reach out to and hear from an amazing group of serious political thinkers. We consider our book a journey of inquiry, not a blueprint for action. But we see the action brewing.

As we say at the books end, The next journeya journey of actionwill have to begin in living rooms and meeting halls across the nation. It will have to begin, as American democracy began, in the once-radical notion that 'We the People' are both the mapmakers and the navigators on the great voyage of discovery called democracy. This week has made us more confident that the next journey will have many able guides.

Jacob Hacker and Paul Pierson 3:57 PM Permalink | Trackbacks

Bookmark and Share



Read Jonathan Rowe remembrance and articles
Email Newsletter icon, E-mail Newsletter icon, Email List icon, E-mail List icon Sign up for Free News & Updates

Advertise in WM

buy from Amazon and
support the Monthly