 |
 |
Twenty years after the fall of the Berlin Wall, Gnter Grass still thinks reunification was a bad idea.
By Paul Hockenos
Forty years of writing from Taylor Branch, James Fallows, Katherine Boo, Marjorie Williams, Joshua Micah Marshall, and more.
By the Editors
How a million surveillance cameras in London are proving George Orwell wrong.
By Jamie Malanowski
With help from Washington, the for-profit college industry is loading up millions of low-income students with debt they'll never pay off.
By Stephen Burd
The best recent memoir from republican Washington is a hoax. That should tell you something.
By Joshua Green
|
|
|
|
May 11, 2006
LUTTIG AND BUSH....Last December I wrote about Judge Michael Luttig's seriously pissed off opinion in the case of Jose Padilla, the "dirty bomber." Basically, the Bush administration argued for years that it was absolutely essential to the war on terror for Padilla to be locked up as an enemy combatant in a military prison, but then, suddenly and cynically, changed its mind when it looked like there was a chance that Padilla might appeal this decision to the Supreme Court and win.
Today the Wall Street Journal follows up on this, suggesting that Luttig felt personally betrayed by the Bush administration's transparent politicization of the war on terror in this case, and this led to his resignation yesterday: [In September] Judge Luttig, according to a person familiar with the court proceedings, put his own credibility on the line, drawing on his own experience in national-security law and confidence in Bush administration officials he knew. He argued to his colleagues that the government wouldn't have sought such extraordinary powers unless absolutely necessary, this person says.
Then, in November, the administration suddenly announced that it didn't consider Mr. Padilla an enemy combatant any more and would charge him in a regular federal court....A person familiar with the judge's thinking says it's evident [Luttig] felt the government had pulled "the carpet out from under him."
....Instead of granting what the government considered a pro forma request to transfer Mr. Padilla to civilian custody, Judge Luttig ordered the parties to submit arguments over the question. On Dec. 21, Judge Luttig delivered a judicial bombshell: a carefully worded order refusing to move Mr. Padilla until the Supreme Court decided what to do. The order all but accused the Bush administration of misconduct.
Luttig, a super-conservative judge and a devout believer that the adminstration needed extraordinary powers to fight terrorism, suddenly discovered that he had been suckered. When this administration says something is critical to the war on terror, what it really means is that it's politically convenient. If something else is politically convenient tomorrow, they'll flip 180 degrees without batting an eye.
For some reason, Luttig found this unacceptable. And so he's gone.
—Kevin Drum 12:23 PM
Permalink
| Trackbacks
| Comments (56)
A judge with that much integrity --- I'd rather he stayed on the bench.
Posted by: beb on May 11, 2006 at 12:28 PM | PERMALINK
If you are an enemy -- or even possibly an enemy --in Times of War, George Bush must have the right to do anything to you. Otherwise, the terrorists win!
Posted by: Freedom Phukher on May 11, 2006 at 12:29 PM | PERMALINK
I'm posting early so does that make me Al?
Okay here goes:
Always click the link!!!
It's obvious this is more liberal sour grapes. Luttig, an obvious RINO is attempting to rip the carpet out from under President Bush because he was overlooked for a spot on the Supreme Court. Apparently Bush saw through his "conservative" facade and went with stalwarts, Roberts, Myers, and Alito.
Can't you liberals ever tell the whole truth without the constant lies and dissembling?
Okay--how'd I do?
Posted by: Al? on May 11, 2006 at 12:31 PM | PERMALINK
When this administration says something is critical to the war on terror, what it really means is that it's politically convenient.
By jove, I think Kevin's got it!
Posted by: ckelly on May 11, 2006 at 12:32 PM | PERMALINK
Hm. I think Luttig actually wanted to take the job at Boeing. The guy has been on the bench for 15 years and he just found out that he didn't get picked by Bush for the Supreme Court (he was on the shortlist; now there probably won't be another retirement for a couple of years).
I think this says more about the values of Republicans in general than it does about Luttig's purported break with the Bush administration: there's no way most progressive judges would desert the job they believe in to make a few million bucks as the general counsel for Boeing.
Posted by: JR on May 11, 2006 at 12:35 PM | PERMALINK
Boy are these guys slow learners.
Posted by: anonymous on May 11, 2006 at 12:38 PM | PERMALINK
Looks like another Former Republican has just been born.
Welcome to the new life, Judge Luttig!
Posted by: sheerahkahn on May 11, 2006 at 12:39 PM | PERMALINK
When this administration says something is critical to the war on terror, what it really means is that it's politically convenient.
In other news, dog bites man.
Posted by: Ringo on May 11, 2006 at 12:41 PM | PERMALINK
Try and convince me that if a Democrat was the President, he would have fought the war against our terrorist enemies with as much vigor even at the risk of alienating its intensely loyal political supporters like a heavy weight intellectual such as Luttig. That is if the alienation of Luttig from the administration is really what happened here, though I am reluctant to believe the news from sources cited by Kevin.
Posted by: tbrosz on May 11, 2006 at 12:49 PM | PERMALINK
Remember Occam's razor....the simplest explanation is the most likely one. It seems extremely doubtful that Luttig resigned over prrinciple, but rather over MONEY.
He knew that he had no chance of getting on the SCOTUS so he jumped at the chance to take a lucrative position with one of our corporate overlords.
If he really wanted to defeat Bushco, he would have stayed on the bench.
Posted by: sp on May 11, 2006 at 12:49 PM | PERMALINK
"Try and convince me that if a Democrat was the President, he would have fought the war against our terrorist enemies with as much vigor..."
Why bother to "try and convince" you? Your idea of vigor is a guy with a strap-on in his phony flight suit. If it's all going so well, why do you bother to argue about it?
Posted by: Kenji on May 11, 2006 at 12:54 PM | PERMALINK
Tbrosz: "Sources cited by Kevin"? I cited the Wall Street Journal. What were you hoping for?
Posted by: Kevin Drum on May 11, 2006 at 12:55 PM | PERMALINK
Al?, fine job. you twisted logic like a pretzel, just as the real al would!
Posted by: mudwall jackson on May 11, 2006 at 12:56 PM | PERMALINK
tbrosz wrote: "Try and convince me that if a Democrat was the President, he would have fought the war against our terrorist enemies with as much vigor..."
Assuming you are not the fake tbrosz, try and convince me that flip-flopping on Padilla's enemy combatant status at a politically convienent moment is indicative of prosecuting the war on terror with vigor.
Maybe a Democratic president would have politicized the war on terror like this, maybe not, but don't try and hand us this BS about how everything Bush does in cases like these is about winning the war.
Posted by: mmy on May 11, 2006 at 12:56 PM | PERMALINK
Why should anyone bother trying to persuade a member of the dead-ender 30%, tbrosz?
Posted by: sglover on May 11, 2006 at 12:57 PM | PERMALINK
Tbrosz, vigor without competence is like... you.
Bush has elevated al Queda from criminals who happened to score big to mythic uber-terrorists. I'd thank Bush to apply a little less rigor when being so incompetent.
Posted by: Alot on May 11, 2006 at 12:58 PM | PERMALINK
You see Kevin, once you have cited the WSJ it is now tainted in tbrosz's eyes. Only sources too ridiculous fo you to cite are considered legit.
The story that Luttig was pissed at the admin's tactics is old news. It may be that he felt betrayed, but I am sure that high paying job at Boeing he is taking helped ease his pain.
Posted by: David P on May 11, 2006 at 12:58 PM | PERMALINK
Tbrosz: "Sources cited by Kevin"? I cited the Wall Street Journal. What were you hoping for?
Caught by the fake tbrosz, you were.
(Yoda impression at no extra charge.)
Posted by: Doctor Jay on May 11, 2006 at 1:03 PM | PERMALINK
Luttig appears from the WSJ article to be a corporate police-state-loving operative of the worst kind and has trained a generation of like minded horrors now serving the GOP and the Bush administration. I think he was just throwing a hissy fit here.
Check out this part of the WSJ article about telling the Bush adminstration lawyer how he should frame an argument for Federal executive powers little different from domestic marshal law :
At oral arguments in the Padilla case last year, Judge Luttig laid out a clear theory by which the Second Circuit's reasoning could be rebutted, at times seeming to lead the government's lawyer, Solicitor General Paul Clement, along with him.
After Mr. Clement referred to the Padilla incarceration as a "nonbattlefield detention," Judge Luttig suggested another approach. "In effect, Mr. Clement, doesn't the United States have to be arguing that, at least in the war on terror, the battlefield includes the United States?" the judge asked. After repeated pressing, Mr. Clement agreed: "I am prepared to say that this is a battlefield."
Posted by: ChetBob on May 11, 2006 at 1:03 PM | PERMALINK
What, Bush disloyal to someone who showed him loyalty?
That just never happens . . .
. . . ask Colin Powell!
;-)
Posted by: Advocate for God on May 11, 2006 at 1:10 PM | PERMALINK
At the core of Luttig's efforts on behalf of the government's position was a core faith in the integrity of the Administration. "I assumed they had a really good reason" for incarcerating Padilla, he said.
So he went to bat for them and twisted arms of the other two judges on the panel with him, and delivered the result. Only to find out that no, they didn't really, and would be happy to transfer him to civilian authority if it was convenient to them.
I don't wonder at his subsequent actions, I only wonder at how Judge Luttig managed to get to his age and position without developing some, er, skepticism. Lawyers are supposed to be trained in critical thinking, no?
Though, I say let's don't spend energy trashing Judge Luttig, but keep our focus on the real threat to the Constitution -- the current administration. What makes them such a threat is their very shallowness and lack of principles as shown by this case.
Posted by: Doctor Jay on May 11, 2006 at 1:10 PM | PERMALINK
ChetBob has what I think is a good point. The assertion that the USA is one of the battlefields in the woron terra is a real "Eek!" generator for me.
I suppose there is a silver lining. After all, if Porter Goss has a concealed weapons permit, a future President might be able to have him rendered to Kazakhstan to answer a few questions before the decision is overturned. Or say, Karl Rove.
It would be irresponsible to not do so!
Damn you ChetBob! Now I have Pat Benatar in my head because of the last 3 words of that post.
Posted by: kenga on May 11, 2006 at 1:12 PM | PERMALINK
"Okay--how'd I do?
Posted by: Al? on May 11, 2006 at 12:31 PM |"
Not bad, but you mis-spelled "LIEberals;" 3 demerits. Watch 5 hours of FoxNews, and say "The President has a clear strategy for victory in Iraq!" ten times.
Posted by: smartalek on May 11, 2006 at 1:14 PM | PERMALINK
Always click the link!!!
It's obvious this is more liberal sour grapes. Luttig, an obvious RINO is attempting to rip the carpet out from under President Bush because he was overlooked for a spot on the Supreme Court. Apparently Bush saw through his "conservative" facade and went with stalwarts, Roberts, Myers, and Alito.
i clicked the link and all i could find to point to this statement was the response from the bush adm.
it seems to me that after the judge got dumped on by this man-uver he felt the need for a shower and responded .
where i come frome actions speak louder than spin
Posted by: rockcrawler on May 11, 2006 at 1:14 PM | PERMALINK
Try and convince me that if a Democrat was the President, he would have fought the war against our terrorist enemies with as much vigor
Aparently, fighting the war with vigor means changing the reason for the war every time the last one is proven bogus. Vigor also means going in with no plan for what happens after defeating Saddam's Army, which, face it, was the easy part. Vigor also means going from "Wanted, Dead or Alive" to "We've inconvienenced him" (or whatever bullshit word he used in the campaign).
I doubt I can convince you of anything, but my fervent hope is that whatever Democrat President gets to lead in the war on terror certainly doesn't match Bush's vigor.
Posted by: tomeck on May 11, 2006 at 1:21 PM | PERMALINK
rockcrawler: where i come frome actions speak louder than spin
Where you come from, little green men rule the Earth.
Better find your anti-psychotics, and quickly!
BTW, if actions speak louder than spin, you must be really disappointed in Bush's failures in Iraq, the economy, capturing bin Laden, port security, Social Security reform, Every Child Left Behind, Roadmap to Nowhere, and his Global Whine on Terror.
Posted by: Advocate for God on May 11, 2006 at 1:24 PM | PERMALINK
*sigh* Why does Judge Luttig hate America...?
Posted by: Stefan on May 11, 2006 at 1:38 PM | PERMALINK
BTW, if actions speak louder than spin, you must be really disappointed in Bush's failures in Iraq, the economy, capturing bin Laden, port security, Social Security reform, Every Child Left Behind, Roadmap to Nowhere, and his Global Whine on Terror.
sorry was there some confusion about that
bush/spin verses judge/action
Posted by: rockcrawler on May 11, 2006 at 1:39 PM | PERMALINK
there's no way most progressive judges would desert the job they believe in to make a few million bucks as the general counsel for Boeing.
Posted by: JR on May 11, 2006 at 12:35 PM | PERMALINK
That's because they enjoy engaging in judicial activism more. What's the point of being a know-it-all busybody if you can't impose your political views on the body politic?
Posted by: Chicounsel on May 11, 2006 at 1:47 PM | PERMALINK
A Lot of Speculation Going On
In the interview, Luttig said that "no one can or should plan their life around a potential Supreme Court vacancy. This decision had nothing whatsoever to do with the Supreme Court process. It was about my family and my son and daughter."
This doesnt stop some from speculating that he is not being honest. From the NRO:
"It is hard not to speculate that his decision to leave the bench for the private sector is motivated, at least in part, by a belief he is no longer a likely nominee to the U.S. Supreme Court."
http://bench.nationalreview.com/post/?q=NDhlMmUwNzc5MzhiNzVmOGY1NDBlNDljOWE2ZDc2ZTQ=
Furthermore, Lutig's loss of respect in the Bush administration might have played a role, but this is also highly speculative especially since his resignation means Bush is getting to name his replacement.
Perhaps Lutig didnt care as much about the administration of justice as everyone thought he did? Perhaps his recent decision made him rethink his life's priorities?
Who knows why he left, however, the handling of the Padilla case and the cynical manipulation of the court system by the Bush administration certainly might have influenced his decision. Then again, maybe we should just take him for his word when he says he is doing it mostly for the money.
Posted by: Catch22 on May 11, 2006 at 2:21 PM | PERMALINK
Occam's razor indeed. If he wants to spend time w/ his family, as implied, going to be GC of Boeing is not the way to do it.
Clearly he is pissed he got passed over for the SCT and sandbagged by the admin. on Padilla. He's not going to stop drinking the koolaid, but he's out to get some moolah for himself. And what better way to do it then hook up with a BIG Defense contractor? How nice.
Posted by: moe99 on May 11, 2006 at 2:29 PM | PERMALINK
Vigor without competence is just wankery. All of the vigorous 101st Fighting Keyboarders are living proof of this statement.
Posted by: Baldrick on May 11, 2006 at 2:33 PM | PERMALINK
And then the supreme court dropped the ball -- saying in essence that the squirrelly maneuver had succeeding in making the current defense appeal "hypothetical".
Posted by: toast on May 11, 2006 at 2:40 PM | PERMALINK
Kevin, why can't you tell the whole story? Luttig's rant was overturned unanimously by the Supreme Court. Maybe it was his embarassment at being exposed as a pure whiney ass tittie baby that led to this resignation.
Posted by: Atrios? on May 11, 2006 at 2:42 PM | PERMALINK
If this Luttig fucker were at least a patriot, he would publicly denounce Bush and his administration for playing politics with national security. Instead he resigns and takes a job representing a defense contractor at about $1 Million/year. Is it a payoff to keep quiet?
Posted by: Hostile on May 11, 2006 at 2:53 PM | PERMALINK
What's the point of being a know-it-all busybody if you can't impose your political views on the body politic?
I'm not sure, but I'll make sure to ask Scalia that the next time I see him. I'll even make sure to ask in Sicilian....
Posted by: Stefan on May 11, 2006 at 2:53 PM | PERMALINK
Scalia will most probably understand a hand gesture better.
Posted by: lib on May 11, 2006 at 2:58 PM | PERMALINK
Atrios?: Luttig's rant was overturned unanimously by the Supreme Court.
Atrios? obviously missing the point.
Posted by: Advocate for God on May 11, 2006 at 3:00 PM | PERMALINK
I think it's about the money plus the fact that he knows that he pissed off enough political appointees with the Padilla order THAT HE WILL NEVER GET ON THE SUPREME COURT.
Atrios?, you don't know what you are talking about. As the original article says, Luttig issued "a carefully worded order refusing to move Mr. Padilla until the Supreme Court decided what to do." The Supreme Court did not overrule him, it simply allowed for him to be transferred. The Supreme Court had to be the decider b/c it will ultimately decide the outcome of the underlying case, which the gov't tried to avoid allowing to reach the Supreme Court at this point b/c it knows it would lose.
Posted by: bob on May 11, 2006 at 3:21 PM | PERMALINK
"Try and convince me that if a Democrat was the President, he would have fought the war against our terrorist enemies with as much vigor ..."
No, thank you, tbrosz.
Why would I want to hit my head against your brick wall of ignorant conviction?
Anyone who's been here for a while understands the futility of trying to convince you of anything reasonable.
Posted by: Cal Gal on May 11, 2006 at 3:33 PM | PERMALINK
Basically, the Bush administration argued for years that it was absolutely essential to the war on terror for Padilla to be locked up as an enemy combatant in a military prison, but then, suddenly and cynically, changed its mind when it looked like there was a chance that Padilla might appeal this decision to the Supreme Court and win.
Why is such an action overly political or cynical?
It seems to me that, if you belive policy "A" is right for the country, and you know a certain court action could bring about a judgement detrimental to carrying out said policy, it simply makes sense to make a tactical retreat. It's called choosing your battles. I think Luttig's being a little drama queen over this. Apparently you liberals won't be satisfied until Bush decided to outsource the relevant policy making to the ACLU.
Posted by: Viv on May 11, 2006 at 3:38 PM | PERMALINK
Feeding the trolls is pointless.
When they're the fake trolls, even more so.
Posted by: sleepy on May 11, 2006 at 3:39 PM | PERMALINK
What he SHOULD have done was stay on in his position and fight the Bushies. Now they'll just replace him with a yesman and go on their marry way.
Posted by: MNPundit on May 11, 2006 at 3:39 PM | PERMALINK
The following excerpt is taken from a e-mail from a law clerk in the 4th Circuit that was sent to Jonah Goldberg and posted in the Corner.
"I also don't think conservatives have paid enough attention to how embarrassingly wrong he was in his opinion refusing to transfer Padilla, regardless of what we think as a policy matter of the decision to charge him in the civilian system (a decision I think was ill-advised). There are good reasons to wonder whether someone who would write such an opinion should have been nominated to the Supreme Court.
The Padilla opinion might have made a good newspaper op-ed, but it was reversed unanimously by the Supreme Court for the very good reason that no legal basis exists for the judiciary to force the President to keep someone in military custody. Luttig never identified any basis for this totally novel judicial power. Padilla didn't want to be in military custody, the President didn't want to keep him in military custody, and that should have been the end of the matter, as Judge Traxler, a non-activist conservative not prone to placing written tantrums in the Federal Reports, recognized, as did every Justice of the Supreme Court. There's nothing noble or admirable about going off the rails and issuing an order not supported by any identifiable provision of law, that also isn't sought by either of the parties before the court. We don't have a European system of inquisitorial justice where judges are entrepeneurs who can roam widely and "do justice" in that fashion, and the worst possible place to start with such an approach would be in the context of the President's power as Commander in Chief over military detentions."
I am not familar enough with Luttig's decision in the Padilla case to comment. Just thought it was worthy of posting given who wrote it.
Oh and Stefan and lib, I'm sure I can speak for Justice Scalia by saying "I got your hand gestures right here buddy!!!" lol
Posted by: Chicounsel on May 11, 2006 at 3:40 PM | PERMALINK
Viv,
If you believe policy "A" is right you should be willing to test it in Court.
Its called due process. A nation of laws. Democracy.
Posted by: sleepy on May 11, 2006 at 3:44 PM | PERMALINK
While I may not personally agree with his views, I am absolutely thrilled that my employer grabbed him.
Posted by: anon on May 11, 2006 at 3:54 PM | PERMALINK
Viv: It seems to me that, if you belive policy "A" is right for the country, and you know a certain court action could bring about a judgement detrimental to carrying out said policy, it simply makes sense to make a tactical retreat.
A tactical retreat from both reality and legality.
Nice trick.
But that's all it is.
I guess that means it was alright for Clinton to lie, because he knew what was right for the country, to get on with the business of government rather than self-righteous rightwing moralizing, and that was simply a tactical retreat from a potentially adverse court ruling.
And of course it is okay for Iran to keep IAEA inspectors out, so they can tactically avoid an adverse IAEA finding on their nuclear programs and do what's in the best interest of their country.
Gotcha.
Posted by: Advocate for God on May 11, 2006 at 5:58 PM | PERMALINK
. . . a law clerk in the 4th Circuit . . .
Yeah, now that's a credible source! A law clerk from the most conservative and partisan ciruit.
Think not.
There's nothing noble or admirable about going off the rails and issuing an order not supported by any identifiable provision of law, that also isn't sought by either of the parties before the court.
Like Bush v. Gore, eh?
Posted by: Advocate for God on May 11, 2006 at 6:02 PM | PERMALINK
"For some reason, Luttig found this unacceptable. And so he's gone."
This doesn't necessarily follow. The article doesn't source anyone as saying Luttig was forced out. "Source familiar with [his] thinking" blah blah.
I don't believe it's even possible for the Executive Branch to fire an Article III judge. That can only be done by Congress (I think), and then only as a result of bad behavior.
The job was his as long as he wanted it. Kudos to him for sticking it to the administration over the Padilla case, but now he's kinda undercutting his own message. If he's that disgusted with Bush et. al., why doesn't he stay in office where he can actively oppose further politicization? Especially considering the Fourth Circuit's reputation as Bush's home field advantage?
Posted by: kwo on May 11, 2006 at 9:13 PM | PERMALINK
A conservative judge with at least some integrity? Now we know why he didn't get one of the Supreme Court vacancies.
Posted by: EvanstonDem on May 11, 2006 at 9:45 PM | PERMALINK
Here's another money quote from the WSJ piece:
People close to the Bush administration see it differently. They dismiss Judge Luttig's opinion as a judicial tantrum, noting that it came after he was passed over three times for a Supreme Court position. President Bush nominated Judge Roberts, Harriet Miers (who withdrew) and Judge Samuel Alito.
These people do not admit the existence of the thing called "principle". Everything is politics to them.
Posted by: brooksfoe on May 11, 2006 at 9:49 PM | PERMALINK
Beb:
If he had integrity he would have made his original Padilla decision on the law, not on informal understandings and personal relationships. It's also disgraceful that the other two judges went along with this. Granted, he's not a complete Bush zombie and has some pride. But he should be gone. Is there a 'strict constructionist' with the courage of his or her convictions sitting on the bench anywhere?
DanG
Posted by: DanG on May 11, 2006 at 9:58 PM | PERMALINK
And also this:
The judge's letter was noteworthy in part for what it didn't say. Instead of praising President Bush, he expressed his "heartfelt thanks to your father, because of whom my professional dreams in life came true."
Wow. Now that is a diss.
I will probably never agree with anything Michael Luttig ever says again in his career, given his political sympathies. But what's happening here is all rooted in the internal inconsistencies and incoherence of the conservative political mind. The Padilla case threw that incoherence into high relief, and made it clear that the real No.1 conservative principle at this point is "The Fuhrer is always right" - which has increasingly forced conservatives to wend their way through tortuous and insane travesties of reasoning over the past 5 years. When you force your followers to commit to such insanely convoluted arguments, you run the risk of eventually losing those of them who still retain some semblance of an intellectual conscience, particularly those who, like judges, have a professional stake in being seen to take their own statements and arguments seriously (except of course for Justice Scalia, who is freely willing to admit that his decision in Bush v. Gore was based on personal prejudice). Anyway, the Piper took one too many sharp turns for Luttig, and he stopped following.
Posted by: brooksfoe on May 11, 2006 at 10:01 PM | PERMALINK
I second DanG!
An Appeals Court decision written because of"special circumstances" by someone who clerked at USSC, and was aide to CJUSSC, in and of itself should be grounds for removing him from any further consideration for higher office.
The Padilla decision was not about whether he was righthanded and the gun was in the left hand and it was Friday and he was at work and his cousin was on the phone with him at 10:34 and he was at the ATM......
This decision was to find if there are ANY limits to "I say so".
An American citizen, arrested on American soil, incarcerrated indefinitely on the sole "word" of the President.
John Yoo or Thomas Paine!
Posted by: P.C.Chapman on May 11, 2006 at 11:21 PM | PERMALINK
The bill has come due to the adminstration, and the WSJ knows this. The publishing of the Iran letter was only the first polite dunning letter.
We're starting at 29% approval, and that's before they have even begun to try to save themselves. They are still in fantasy land that they can PR out of this. The administration does not look like to last out the summer.
Posted by: patience on May 12, 2006 at 2:54 AM | PERMALINK
discount online pharmacy discount online pharmacy,
discount pharmacy UK discount pharmacy UK,
buy pharmacy buy pharmacy,
buy pharmacy online buy pharmacy online,
internet pharmacy internet pharmacy,
pharmacy drugs pharmacy drugs,
foreign pharmacy foreigh pharmacy,
discount pharmacy discount pharmacy,
mortgage mortgage,
mortgage refinancing mortgage refinancing,
mortgage calculator mortgage calculator,
home mortgage home mortgage,
mortgage rate mortgage rate,
second mortgage second mortgage,
mortgage quote mortgage quote,
mortgage company mortgage company,
2nd mortgage 2nd mortgage,
mortgage loan mortgage loan,
florida mortgage florida mortgage,
bad credit mortgage, bad credit mortgage,
mortgage broker, mortgage broker,
mortgage lender, mortgage lender,
reverse mortgage, reverse mortgage,
mortgage lead, mortgage lead,
california mortgage, california mortgage,
best mortgage rate, best mortgage rate,
mortgage interest rate, mortgage interest rate,
adjustable rate mortgage, adjustable rate mortgage,
california mortgage loan, california mortgage loan,
gmac mortgage, gmac mortgage,
countrywide mortgage, countrywide mortgage,
texas mortgage, texas mortgage,
online mortgage, online mortgage,
california mortgage rate, california mortgage rate,
current mortgage rate, current mortgage rate,
mortgage payment, mortgage payment,
mortgage marketing, mortgage marketing,
florida mortgage lender, florida mortgage lender,
commercial mortgage, commercial mortgage,
national city mortgage, national city mortgage,
florida mortgage broker, florida mortgage broker,
mortgage insurance, mortgage insurance,
home mortgage rate, home mortgage rate,
lowest mortgage rate, lowest mortgage rate,
north carolina mortgage, north carolina mortgage,
bad credit loan mortgage, bad credit loan mortgage,
best mortgage, best mortgage,
bad credit mortgage refinance, bad credit mortgage refinance,
arizona mortgage, arizona mortgage,
mortgage new york, mortgage new york,
home mortgage interest rate, home mortgage interest rate,
mortgage washington, mortgage washington,
interest only mortgage, interest only mortgage,
mortgage financing, mortgage financing,
internet mortgage lead, internet mortgage lead,
maryland mortgage, maryland mortgage,
missouri mortgage, missouri mortgage,
finance mortgage, finance mortgage,
colorado mortgage, colorado mortgage,
refinance mortgage rate, refinance mortgage rate,
option one mortgage, option one mortgage,
mortgage houston, mortgage houston,
refinance mortgage loan, refinance mortgage loan,
mortgage protection, mortgage protection,
home equity mortgage, home equity mortgage,
nevada mortgage, nevada mortgage,
michigan mortgage, michigan mortgage,
new century mortgage, new century mortgage,
mortgage interest, mortgage interest,
bad credit mortgage lender, bad credit mortgage lender,
fixed rate mortgage, fixed rate mortgage,
washington mutual mortgage, washington mutual mortgage,
second mortgage loan, second mortgage loan,
american home mortgage, american home mortgage,
low mortgage rate, low mortgage rate,
california mortgage broker, california mortgage broker,
conventional mortgage, conventional mortgage,
debt consolidation mortgage, debt consolidation mortgage,
wisconsin wholesale mortgage, wisconsin wholesale mortgage,
mortgage application, mortgage application,
equity mortgage, equity mortgage,
mortgage note buyer, mortgage note buyer,
mortgage dallas, mortgage dallas,
first mortgage, first mortgage,
hawaii mortgage, hawaii mortgage,
mortgage chicago, mortgage chicago,
mortgage rate calculator, mortgage rate calculator,
fha mortgage, fha mortgage,
residential mortgage, residential mortgage,
mortgage georgia, mortgage georgia,
new jersey mortgage, new jersey mortgage,
california mortgage purchase, california mortgage purchase,
fixed mortgage, fixed mortgage,
indiana mortgage, indiana mortgage,
miami mortgage, miami mortgage,
illinois mortgage illinois mortgage
car insurance, car insurance,
insurance, insurance,
health insurance, health insurance,
home insurance, home insurance,
life insurance, life insurance,
auto insurance quote, auto insurance quote,
home owner insurance, home owner insurance,
travel insurance, travel insurance,
auto cheap insurance, auto cheap insurance,
dental insurance, dental insurance,
insurance quote, insurance quote,
term life insurance, term life insurance,
insurance carrier broker agent, insurance carrier broker agent,
medical insurance, medical insurance,
car insurance rate, car insurance rate,
business insurance, business insurance,
renters insurance, renters insurance,
insurance broker, insurance broker,
insurance company, insurance company,
life insurance quote, life insurance quote,
state farm insurance, state farm insurance,
health insurance quote, health insurance quote,
auto insurance company, auto insurance company,
online insurance quote, online insurance quote,
affordable health insurance, affordable health insurance,
farmer insurance, farmer insurance,
low cost health insurance, low cost health insurance,
california health insurance, california health insurance,
allstate insurance, allstate insurance,
individual health insurance, individual health insurance,
motorcycle insurance, motorcycle insurance,
progressive insurance, progressive insurance,
insurance lead, insurance lead,
rv insurance, rv insurance,
term insurance, term insurance,
term life insurance quote, term life insurance quote,
boat insurance, boat insurance,
texas health insurance, texas health insurance,
pet insurance, pet insurance,
nationwide insurance, nationwide insurance,
insurance attorney, insurance attorney,
whole life insurance, whole life insurance,
free insurance quote, free insurance quote,
health insurance plan, health insurance plan,
american family insurance, american family insurance,
long term care insurance, long term care insurance,
progressive auto insurance, progressive auto insurance,
insurance online, insurance online,
health insurance illinois, health insurance illinois,
online car insurance, online car insurance,
health insurance coverage, health insurance coverage,
auto insurance rate, auto insurance rate,
affordable insurance, affordable insurance,
life insurance policy, life insurance policy,
auto insurance online, auto insurance online,
student health insurance, student health insurance,
insurance adjuster, insurance adjuster,
mercury insurance, mercury insurance,
health insurance company, health insurance company,
family health insurance, family health insurance,
florida health insurance, florida health insurance,
disability insurance, disability insurance,
group health insurance, group health insurance,
cheap health insurance, cheap health insurance,
liability insurance, liability insurance,
travel health insurance, travel health insurance,
new york car insurance, new york car insurance,
online auto insurance quote, online auto insurance quote,
mortgage insurance, mortgage insurance,
international health insurance, international health insurance,
insurance rate, insurance rate,
insurance policy, insurance policy,
california health insurance quote, california health insurance quote,
flood insurance, flood insurance,
temporary health insurance, temporary health insurance,
home owner insurance quote, home owner insurance quote,
property insurance, property insurance,
short term health insurance, short term health insurance,
life insurance company, life insurance company,
free health insurance quote, free health insurance quote,
affordable car insurance, affordable car insurance,
employment insurance, employment insurance,
major medical insurance, major medical insurance,
insurance agent, insurance agent,
florida car insurance, florida car insurance,
traveler insurance, traveler insurance,
21st century insurance, 21st century insurance,
health insurance ca, health insurance ca,
texas department of insurance, texas department of insurance,
low cost life insurance, low cost life insurance,
car insurance chicago, car insurance chicago,
aaa insurance, aaa insurance,
international medical insurance, international medical insurance,
life insurance rate, life insurance rate,
california health insurance plan, california health insurance plan,
dental insurance plan, dental insurance plan,
self employed health insurance, self employed health insurance,
usaa insurance, usaa insurance,
hartford insurance hartford insurance
top summer vacation, top summer vacation,
america next top model, america next top model,
top movie, top movie
top model, top model,
counter tops, counter tops,
top gear, top gear,
america top model, america top model,
top story, top story,
top news story, top news story,
top search, top search,
top song, top song,
next top model, next top model,
american next top model, american next top model,
top news, top news,
top teen model, top teen model,
top of the world, top of the world,
american top model, american top model,
top secret, top secret,
top shop, top shop,
top franchise top franchise
zip code look up, zip code look up,
phone number look up, phone number look up,
phone look up, phone look up
Free search engine free search engine
pay per click search engine pay per click search engine
web search engine, web search engine
search, search
search engine, search engine
portal, portal
internet portal internet portal
pay per click search enginepay per click search engine
online search engine online search engine
ppc search engine ppc search engine
ppc advertising ppc advertising
pay per click advertising pay per click advertising
ppc affiliate program ppc affiliate program
search engine affiliate program search engine affiliate program
online casino, online casino,
internet casino, internet casino,
casino game, casino game,
online casino gambling, online casino gambling,
best online casino, best online casino
casino gambling, casino gambling,
internet casino gambling, internet casino gambling,
vegas casino, vegas casino,
casino gaming, casino gaming,
casino bonus, casino bonus,
casino slot, casino slot,
10 best online casino, 10 best online casino,
grand casino, grand casino,
virtual casino, virtual casino,
casino on line, casino on line,
internet casino gambling online, internet casino gambling online,
casino chips, casino chips,
online gambling casino, online gambling casino
best online casino gambling, best online casino gambling
casino portal, casino portal,
best casino, best casino,
online casino bonus, online casino bonus,
top online casino, top online casino,
gambling casino online, gambling casino online,
jackpot casino, jackpot casino,
casino black jack, casino black jack,
casino baccarat, casino baccarat,
casino gamble, casino gamble,
online casino slot, online casino slot,
casino roulette, casino roulette,
casino on the net casino on the net
host, host
cheap host web, cheap host web,
domain host, domain host,
host image, host image,
dedicated host, dedicated host,
host top web, host top web,
ecommerce host web, ecommerce host web,
host internet, host internet,
cheap host, cheap host,
affordable host site web, affordable host site web,
host services, host services,
host php, host php
computer, computer,
notebook computer, notebook computer,
dell computer, dell computer,
desktop computer, desktop computer,
computer software, computer software,
computer store, computer store,
computer sale, computer sale,
computer computer, computer computer,
computer hardware, computer hardware,
computer electronics, computer electronics,
computer internet, computer internet,
discount computer, discount computer,
computer memory, computer memory,
computer part, computer part,
apple computer, apple computer,
computer accessory, computer accessory,
computer system, computer system,
computer monitor, computer monitor,
buy computer, buy computer,
hp computer, hp computer,
gateway computer, gateway computer,
computer cases, computer cases,
computer hardware equipment, computer hardware equipment,
computer equipment, computer equipment,
computer furniture, computer furniture,
cheap computer, cheap computer,
computer storage, computer storage,
personal computer, personal computer,
computer mouse, computer mouse,
computer networking equipment, computer networking equipment,
computer speaker, computer speaker,
used computer, used computer,
computer shopping, computer shopping,
computer cable, computer cable,
gaming computer, gaming computer,
computer keyboard, computer keyboard,
computer armoire, computer armoire,
compaq computer, compaq computer,
wholesale computer hardware, wholesale computer hardware,
multimedia computer, multimedia computer,
portable computer, portable computer,
computer hardware and software, computer hardware and software,
california computer, california computer,
computer component, computer component,
computer ohio, computer ohio,
cheap notebook computer, cheap notebook computer,
buying a computer, buying a computer
acer computer acer computer
herbal supplement, herbal supplement
herbal, herbal
herbal medicine, herbal medicine
herbal remedy, herbal remedy
herbal tea, herbal tea
herbal breast enhancement, herbal breast enhancement
herbal life, herbal life
buy herbal product, buy herbal product
herbal essence, herbal essence
herbal cleanse, herbal cleanse
herbal cleansing, herbal cleansing
herbal magic, herbal magic
herbal weight loss, herbal weight loss
herbal product, herbal product
quit smoking herbal, quit smoking herbal
herbal smoke herbal smoke
herbal store herbal store
herbal nutrition supplement herbal nutrition supplement
herbal skin care herbal skin care
herbal nutrition herbal nutrition
weight loss weight loss
weight loss pill weight loss pill
weight loss pills weight loss pills
weight loss diet weight loss diet
weight loss program weight loss program
LA weight loss LA weight loss
weight loss product weight loss product
weight loss supplements weight loss supplements
fast weight loss fast weight loss
quick weight loss quick weight loss
weight loss drugs weight loss drugs
Natural weight loss Natural weight loss
weight loss medication weight loss medication
Healthy weight loss healthy weight loss
Rapid weight loss rapid weight loss
weight loss tips weight loss tips
Green tea weight loss green tea weight loss
weight loss diet pills weight loss diet pills
weight loss online weight loss online
online weight loss online weight loss
best weight loss program best weight loss program
easy weight loss easy weight loss
weight loss patch weight loss patch
weight loss information weight loss information
weight loss prescription weight loss prescription
herbal weight loss herbal weight loss
hoodia weight loss hoodia weight loss
rapid weight loss pills rapid weight loss pills
best weight loss pills best weight loss pills
weight loss help weight loss help
weight loss system weight loss system
weight loss wellbutrin weight loss wellbutrin
wellbutrin weight loss wellbutrin weight loss
buy wellbutrin buy wellbutrin
order wellbutrin order wellbutrin
order wellbutrin online order wellbutrin online
generic wellbutrin generic wellbutrin
cheap wellbutrin cheap wellbutrin
buy wellbutrin online buy wellbutrin online
herb weight loss herb weight loss
weight loss herb weight loss herb
weight loss prescription pills weight loss prescription pills
best weight loss supplement best weight loss supplement
free weight loss tips free weight loss tips
weight loss tea weight loss tea
Herbal products - herbal remedie, herbal producs
Breast enlargement - breast enlargement, increase breast size naturaly
Generic proscar - buy cheap proscar pills online
Generic propecia - buy propecia online, cheap discount propecia
casino strategies casino strategies
casino directory casino directory
gambling tips gambling tips
casino consultant casino consultant
casino bonus casino bonus
10 best online casino 10 best online casino
casino gambling casino gambling
download adult movies download adult movies
adult sex movies adult sex movies
free adult movies free adult movies
adult english movies adult english movies
xxx adult movies xxx adult movies
adult movie clips adult movie clips
adult dvd movies adult dvd movies
adult movie trailer adult movie trailer
adult porn movies adult porn movies
adult movie database adult movie database
adult movie sample adult movie sample
adult movies online adult movies online
adult movies online adult movies online
adult friend finder adult friend finder
adult dvd adult dvd
adult video adult video
adult sex adult sex
adult search engine adult search engine
adult toy adult toy
adult movies dvd adult movies dvd
adult web cam chat adult web cam chat
adult dating personals adult dating personals
adult movies dvd adult movies dvd
adult ecard adult ecard
adult sex adult sex
adult pics adult pics
adult portal adult portal
porn star finder porn star finder
pornstar finder pornstar finder
porn star search porn star search
pornstar search pornstar search
pornstar search pornstar search
pornstar search pornstar search
pornstar search pornstar search
pornstar search pornstar search
adult toys store adult toys store
adult toys adult toys
adult toy store adult toy store
adult toy adult toy
discount adult toys discount adult toys
discounted adult toys discounted adult toys
love dolls love dolls
adult toy vibrator adult toy vibrator
adult sex toy store adult sex toy store
erotic sex toys erotic sex toys
discount adult toys discount adult toys
discounted adult toys discounted adult toys
love dolls love dolls
adult toy vibrator adult toy vibrator
adult sex toy store adult sex toy store
erotic sex toys erotic sex toys
discount sex toys discount sex toys
cheap sex toys cheap sex toys
buy sex toys buy sex toys
glass dildo glass dildo
male sex toys male sex toys
female sex toys female sex toys
women sex toys women sex toys
internet portal internet portal
recent news recent news
internet search internet search
find porn stars find favorite porn stars
porn star Crissy Moran porn star Crissy Moran
porn star Tyler Faith porn star Tyler Faith
porn star Ashton Moore porn star Ashton Moore
porn star Krystal Steal porn star Krystal Steal
porn star Jenna Jameson porn star Jenna Jameson
porn star Stormy Daniels porn star Stormy Daniels
porn star Briana Banks porn star Briana Banks
porn star Alexis Amore porn star Alexis Amore
porn star Brittany Andrews porn star Brittany Andrews
porn star Tera Patrick porn star Tera Patrick
porn star Gina Lynn porn star Gina Lynn
porn star Jill Kelly porn star Jill Kelly
porn star Sophia Rossi porn star Sophia Rossi
porn star Summer Skyes porn star Summer Skyes
porn star Jesse Capelli porn star Jesse capelli
porn star Lonnie Waters porn star Lonnie Waters
porn star Jenna Heart porn star Jenna Heart
porn star Natalia Cruze porn star Natalia Cruze
porn star Teri Summers porn star Teri Summers
porn star Anita Dark porn star Anita Dark
porn star Ginger Jolie porn star Ginger Jolie
porn star Alexa Kai porn star Alexa Kai
porn star Breana porn star Breana
porn star Crystal Klein porn star Crystal Klein
porn star Kelle Marie porn star Kelle Marie
porn star Jamie Lynn porn star Jamie Lynn
centerfold Barbie Griffin centerfold Barbie Griffin
centerfold Zdenka Podkapova centerfold Zdenka Podkapova
porn star Tall Goddess porn star Tall Goddess
porn star Sky Lopez porn star Sky Lopez
porn star Penny Flame porn star Penny Flame
porn star Nikki Nova porn star Nikki Nova
porn star Tanya James porn star Tanya James
porn star Avy Scott porn star Avy Scott
porn star Monique Alexander porn star Monique Alexander
porn star Mason Marconi porn star Mason Marconi
porn star Bobbie Eden porn star Bobbie Eden
porn star Britney Foster porn star Britney Foster
centerfold Coco Johnsen centerfold Coco Johnsen
porn star Maliyah Madison porn star Maliyah Madison
porn star Lacey Duvalle porn star Lacey Duvalle
porn star Kylie Wyld porn star Kylie Wyld
porn star Kira Eggers porn star Kira Eggers
porn star Jessica Darling porn star Jessica Darling
porn star Jana Cova porn star Jana Cova
porn star Dru Berrymore porn star Dru Berrymore
porn star Deja Chan porn star Deja Chan
porn star Dani Woodward porn star Dani Woodward
porn star Amber Rain porn star Amber Rain
porn star Allysin Chaynes porn star Allysin Chaynes
porn star Tyler Fox porn star Tyler Fox
porn star Taylor Ann porn star Taylor Ann
porn star Nakita Kash porn star Nakita Kash
porn star Charlie Laine porn star Charlie Laine
porn star Domino porn star Domino
porn star Becky Le Sabre porn star Becky Le Sabre
porn star Kaylani Lei porn star Kaylani Lei
porn star Katja Kassin porn star Katja Kassin
porn star Victoria Red porn star Victoria Red
porn star Nautica Thorn porn star Nautica Thorn
porn star Veronica Zemanova porn star Veronica Zemanova
porn star Kyla Cole porn star Kyla Cole
porn star Aria Giovanni porn star Aria Giovanni
porn star Erica Campbell porn star Erica Campbell
porn star Jesse Jane porn star Jesse Jane
porn star Nikki Tyler porn star Nikki TYler
porn star Monica Sweetheart porn star Monica Sweetheart
porn star Katsumi porn star Katsumi
porn star Devon porn star Devon
Posted by: best resource on May 14, 2006 at 4:54 PM | PERMALINK
|
|
|