September 20, 2009
PERRY DOESN'T FEEL YOUR PAIN.... It's understandable that Texas Gov. Rick Perry (R) would want to argue that his economic policies have been effective -- he's seeking re-election next year, and he's facing a very difficult primary challenge.
But he hasn't thought his strategy through. This week, Perry told the Houston Chamber of Commerce that Texas, under his leadership, is "recession-proof." He noted an unidentified report claiming that Texas would be the first to come out of the recession. Perry said he responded to the report by asking, "We're in one?"
So, in the midst of a brutal recession, Perry not only isn't concerned, he thinks Texas' economy is just fine. Texas Monthly's Paul Burka noted the potential political consequences of such a remark: "This gaffe is going to stick.... You cannot be callous and cavalier when people are losing their jobs and their homes. I don't care how ideological the Republican base is. Unemployment in Texas just reached the 8% mark. Everybody knows someone who is suffering in these times. Everybody has lost part of their life savings. It could cost him the race."
Politics aside, if Perry sincerely doesn't even recognize the economic downturn, he must be living in an impenetrable bubble. Texas has been very hard hit by the recession, and the state's most vulnerable families have struggled to keep their heads above water. Texas is the worst state in the country for residents without health care coverage, and is among the worst for poverty rates.
What's more, Lee Fang reminds us, "Texas would have a much higher unemployment rate if it were not for President Obama's stimulus program, which has provided billions in investments and over 70,000 jobs so far. Nonetheless, Perry not only considered rejecting the stimulus, but has called it a 'burden.'"
If there's any justice, this will be a tough one for Perry to live down.
—Steve Benen 8:05 AM
Permalink
| Trackbacks
| Comments (25)
Gov. Good Hair strikes again. Time to get on down the road, Rick!
Posted by: animaux on September 20, 2009 at 8:09 AM | PERMALINK
sadly, in texas, there is very little justice along those lines. hell, in texas the perry campaign can make the claim that kay bailey hutchinson is too liberal to be texas' governor and no one laughs. i might have been an obama delegate to the state democratic convention but the county i live in went 80% for mccain.
Posted by: navarro on September 20, 2009 at 8:11 AM | PERMALINK
Oh boy , is the power of the hair able to extend its reach beyond the ken of mortal men ? Keep your radio sets tuned to these same out of touch and beyond reason personalities for the next mind numbing episode .
Was Perry a step up from Bush , or was this a mere R. E. Lee drag em to the wing until they get tired strategy ?
Whichever one is more suited for the increasingly bizarre public face of the southern party matters little for the humans in Texas .
Posted by: FRP on September 20, 2009 at 8:23 AM | PERMALINK
My God, listening to Perry gives me a creepy deja vu feeling. Where have I heard that same cavalier attitude and dry sense of humor coming via a Texan drawl before.....? Somebody help me, because I can't quit place it.
Posted by: oh my on September 20, 2009 at 8:52 AM | PERMALINK
I also can't quite spell quite, perhaps somebody could help me with that also?
Posted by: oh my on September 20, 2009 at 8:58 AM | PERMALINK
"All together, Houston lost 95,100 jobs between August 2008 and August 2009, according to the Texas Workforce Commission. That represents a 3.6 percent loss of jobs over that one-year period." (Houston Chronical; 9.19.09)
I'd take 3.6% here in Albany in a heartbeat, and so would my Governor who is presently positioned under the Van Jones Memorial Obama Busline.
Neither Benen, nor Burka, nor Dr. Christina Romer have a chance in CEA Hell of substantiating those 70,000 jobs.
And 56% of the $14B to the LoneStars went to Medicaid & PubED; you know, er, for the most part FED mandated.
As they say in Lubbock: That stimulus dog wont hunt, it won't even scratch.
Lee Fang isn't as condescendingly blatant or coy a liar as Corley, Faiz or Yglesias; he's certainly strident but doesn't have the big boy BS pants yet.
Posted by: tao9 on September 20, 2009 at 9:33 AM | PERMALINK
It could cost him the race."
oh please. look at who the citizens of texas send to congress election after election after election.
Posted by: linda on September 20, 2009 at 9:34 AM | PERMALINK
I saw the video clip. As bad as Perry's comments were, what was worse was the reaction of the audience.
"We're in a recession?" (LAUGHTER).
His audience isn't feeling the recession. They're the 1/2 of 1 percent who have done quite well out of the Republican economic policies over the last 30 years, thank you, and can't give a damn about the rest of us.
This is how they talk, and laugh among themselves, when they don't think any cameras are watching.
Posted by: kevmo on September 20, 2009 at 9:37 AM | PERMALINK
"This is how they talk, and laugh among themselves, when they don't think any cameras are watching."
Hey, leave Pelosi and Axelrod out of this.
Posted by: tao9 on September 20, 2009 at 9:54 AM | PERMALINK
@tao9
I could throw out a bunch of random numbers and newspaper quotes at random and speak a bunch of jibberish too, but I'll just say this:
Texas stimulus money awarded: $ 16.88 billion
Texas stimulus money paid out to date: $4.13 billion
estimated jobs saved or created (2 year estimate): 269,000
health and human services - $2.4 billion
education - $6.9 billion
included in the Texas package is $1.1 billion for the dept. of defense, $2.7 billion for the dept. of transportation, $517 million for the dept. of housing and urban development, and $755 million for the dept. of energy.
Texas, like many western states that are mineral rich, did very well over the energy boom of the past decade. This looks like a repeat of the 70's energy crisis when these states did well while the nation struggled. When oil and energy prices collapsed and the rest of nation recovered many of the these states then fell on hard times.
I guess Perry is just trying to take credit for what God put in the ground. I suppose he'll also gladly except the blame when the Texas economy struggles to recover?
Posted by: wtf on September 20, 2009 at 10:19 AM | PERMALINK
If there's any justice, this will be a tough one for Perry to live down.
Never doubt the moron stupidity of the average rural white Texan (or the average Houston or Dallas or Midland suburban Texan). Perry will campaign at Friday night football games and tell everyone how much fun we're all havin', and the morons who elected Bush twice as governor and twice as President will "do their duty." Remember all those Aggies grads.
Posted by: TCinLA on September 20, 2009 at 11:01 AM | PERMALINK
"Texas predicted to lead recovery": http://buffalo.bizjournals.com/buffalo/stories/2009/09/14/daily23.html?ana=from_rss
Six of the 20 strongest-performing metro areas are in Texas: http://www.brookings.edu/metro/MetroMonitor/overall_performance/overall.aspx
What Perry says is true, and is significant.
So Benen stupidly fixates on some little rhetorical device which Perry used to distract his followers from awkward reality.
Posted by: am on September 20, 2009 at 11:24 AM | PERMALINK
it's good to know that all the old-timers remain as stupid as ever. no, am, what perry said isn't true: there is a recession in texas....
Posted by: howard on September 20, 2009 at 11:59 AM | PERMALINK
Wow. I've lived in Texas throughout Perry's entire governorship and I never noticed before how much he sounds like Bush. My wife said the same thing, and now we're trying to remember if we've ever heard him talk before. I guess I must have seen him in commercials, but I think he sounded different in a more scripted format. He sounded like he could have been Bush's slightly dumber brother in this clip.
Posted by: Doctor Biobrain on September 20, 2009 at 1:25 PM | PERMALINK
What Perry says is true, and is significant.
Uh, am? The first link you posted states repeatedly that Texas is in a recession, which directly refutes Perry's suggestion that we're not in one. So what was "true" about what he said?
And the reason Benen "fixated" on Perry's comment was because it was boneheaded and callous, and the exact sort of "rhetorical device" which can hurt politicians if more people hear about. I fail to understand what the problem is here.
Posted by: Doctor Biobrain on September 20, 2009 at 1:34 PM | PERMALINK
The Houston Chamber of Commerce got a good laugh out of Perry's comment. Heartless bastards.
Posted by: Chris on September 20, 2009 at 2:02 PM | PERMALINK
Damn, how I miss Molly Ivins.
Although a column about Perry actually writes itself in her voice, doesn't it?
Posted by: efgoldman on September 20, 2009 at 2:40 PM | PERMALINK
8%.
Texas is what? 20million good ol boys?
That's 1.8 million unemployed?
without Obama it would be 1,870,000.
Much higher unemployment?
Not really.
I hate it when you make me fight for their side, but facts have a liberal bias most of the time so we should support facts whenever we can.
Posted by: toowearyforoutrage on September 20, 2009 at 5:09 PM | PERMALINK
"If there's any justice, this will be a tough one for Perry to live down."
In a just world, the rest of us would be spared Texas's special oil-and-fundamentalist-Christian-induced Lone Star brand of crazy.
Posted by: PTate in MN on September 20, 2009 at 5:33 PM | PERMALINK
toowearyforbrainwaveflatline on September 20, 2009 at 5:09 PM:
"Texas is what? 20million good ol boys?"
Texas total pop = 24.6 Mil.
So half are gals, 30-40% or so are kids, and 100% of Austin is metrosexual.
Posted by: tao9 on September 20, 2009 at 6:50 PM | PERMALINK
Before the governors mansion in Austin TX burned several years ago, Gov. Rick Perry (or his office) overruled the governors mansion security office recommendation regarding how many security personnel should be left behind to guard the mansion during renovations.
No report has ever been issued saying how many state security people Gov. Perry took with him to guard him and his family at the luxury mansion on the lake ($10,000 rental a month) that he moved to during renovations.
We know from reports only that too few security people (with faulty surveillance equipment, too boot) were on-site at the governors mansion the night that an arsonist hit.
Which raises the question, in my mind, of whether the arsonist would have gotten close enough to torch the governors mansion if Gov. Perry and his office had heeded the recommendations of the governors mansion security office, instead of leaving a skeleton security crew on-site to keep an eye on the governors mansion?
So, Gov. Perry's callous remark is in keeping with his overall elitist attitude. He just doesn't care about working Texas families, or in the case of the arson attack, the governors mansion.
Posted by: wizard2000 on September 20, 2009 at 7:06 PM | PERMALINK
Texas is a donor state, which means the feds confiscate more tax money from Texas than they give back in the form of stimulus or subsidies or anything else. Obama has done jack s#it for Texas.
Posted by: Texan4Texas on September 20, 2009 at 7:09 PM | PERMALINK
Touche, Tao9.
Yes, one should factor in those not identified as unemployed due to youth or choice.
While we're at it, 8% of 20million is 1.6 million, not 1.8
Duh.
Posted by: toowearyforoutrage on September 20, 2009 at 8:08 PM | PERMALINK
Texas may be a donor state, but I suspect it is because it has a horrible record for taking care of its poor. There is no welfare here, fought SCHIP tooth and nail, does the minimum requirement for unemployment, etc. It is like 49th in the country for poverty and lack of education. Yet we have one of the highest rates of oil and gas revenue to tax. With those kind of savings in spending, how could we not be in the black and a net contributor to the federal government?
For all those who think they would like to secede, I'd like to see the faces of the mob when they find out that the little disability, SCHIP, WIC, etc. that we have would go away completely along with social security and medicare. We would no doubt stone gays and give women who have abortions the lethal injection. If we become a laboratory of democracy, it would be one that Darwin would be proud of - dog eat dog.
Posted by: Always Hopeful on September 21, 2009 at 12:16 AM | PERMALINK
Doesn't Rick Perry know that his primary responsibility is to create fear in his constituency? How else will government grow and become more powerful?
Posted by: Idissent on September 21, 2009 at 8:13 AM | PERMALINK