October 22, 2009
AHIP URGES GOP NOT TO GIVE 'COMFORT TO THE ENEMY'.... Well, I guess it's safe to say private health insurers have no intention of rebuilding burnt bridges. Suzy Khimm noted the other day, "Activists on the left have long insisted that insurance companies aren't to be trusted. But up until now, it's been hard to make the charge stick, since the insurance lobby -- a.k.a., America's Health Insurance Plans -- has been cooperating with the White House and its allies."
That cooperation is officially over.
It started last week with a deceptive report on health care premiums. Soon after, insurers launched a new round of attack ads. Now, Sam Stein reports on the industry's message to Republicans.
A top lobbyist for the major private insurance industry trade group, America's Health Insurance Plans (AHIP), urged Congressional Republicans to not even consider helping Democrats pass health care reform lest they aid an "enemy who is down."
Steve Champlin, a lobbyist for the Duberstein Group who represents AHIP, declared that the road to a bipartisan health care reform bill was, essentially, dead. And he urged GOP members to keep it that way.
"There is absolutely no interest, no reason Republicans should ever vote for this thing. They have gone from a party that got killed 11 months ago to a party that is rising today. And they are rising up on the turmoil of health care," said Champlin. "So when they vote for a health care reform bill, whatever it is, they are giving comfort to the enemy who is down."
Chaplain made the remarks at an annual AHIP conference. He added that he expected reform with some kind of public option to pass, though he emphasized the importance of Republicans standing firm in opposition.
Now, it's worth noting that this isn't especially surprising. Private health insurers don't support health care reform? They consider Democratic policymakers "the enemy"? Well, sure.
Reading this, though, I'm reminded of the Republican Meme of the Week. If the White House criticizes AHIP, and tries to leverage the industry's antics to rally support for reform, the administration, we're told, must be creating an "enemies list." If Obama criticizes insurers, he resembles, we're told, be a modern-day Nixon.
In other words, AHIP can try to derail reform, pressure Republicans to vote in lock-step against improving the broken system, and characterize the majority as "the enemy," but if the White House pushes back, it's the president and his team who are being outrageous.
Our discourse can be awfully frustrating sometimes.
—Steve Benen 12:40 PM
Permalink
| Trackbacks
| Comments (21)
When people feel they're about to lose, they begin talking of "giving comfort to the enemy" and of "being stabbed in the back."
Cheney is complaining of being stabbed in the back by Obama; and AHIP is trying to rally the remnants of the GOP into a last push against the encroaching enemy.
Where are we now? Final days of the Third Reich?
Posted by: SteinL on October 22, 2009 at 12:41 PM | PERMALINK
plus the basic unreality of this assertion: "The GOP have gone from a party that got killed 11 months ago to a party that is rising today. And they are rising up on the turmoil of health care."
i suppose it's possible that the party's numbers are rising among some white men, but i see no evidence that they are rising with any group that elected democrats last fall
Posted by: dj spellchecka on October 22, 2009 at 12:47 PM | PERMALINK
The dying, sick, bankrupt American people are "the enemy" to insurers and the GOP.
Can we get an ad here, pronto?
Posted by: shortstop on October 22, 2009 at 12:50 PM | PERMALINK
AHIP needs to learn how to read polls--it ain't the Dems, or the public option that's "down".
Not by a long shot.
Can't wait to see them take away the anti-trust exemption.
Posted by: Allan Snyder on October 22, 2009 at 12:51 PM | PERMALINK
Did I just fall asleep and wake up in 2002, where it was considered normal to apply Constitional language on treason to Democrats? Is Morning Joe going to invite Jonah Goldberg on to laugh about this?
Posted by: Joshua on October 22, 2009 at 12:51 PM | PERMALINK
Our discourse can be awfully frustrating sometimes.
Only when the MSM decides to back the wrong side.Health Care reform is a no brainer. The corporations responsable for mining our population have , for all intent and purpose, been exposed for what they are and what it is they plan to do. If America ,once again, votes against their own best self interests, why should that be of a surprise to any clear thinker? Nauseating....
Posted by: stevio on October 22, 2009 at 12:54 PM | PERMALINK
Wow, so the insurance lobby is outright telling Republicans to continue to oppose the bill for political reasons? Have they gone freaking insane?? First that joke of a report which only fueled Democratic support for healthcare reform, and now they're explicitly exposing the Republican Party as the partisan sock-puppets we always knew they were. It's like they're not even trying anymore.
Posted by: Doctor Biobrain on October 22, 2009 at 12:54 PM | PERMALINK
Right and how about the CNN 'analyst' , the repiglican called Alex Constalatos .. or something like that ... whose 'media company' that he owns and makes the commercials for this group .... what is CNN going to do about this ? who is going to call them out ?
Posted by: stormskies on October 22, 2009 at 12:56 PM | PERMALINK
It's too goddamn bad we have so many Democrats who are bought and paid for by these criminals. We ought to be putting them out of business once and for all.
Posted by: Steve LaBonne on October 22, 2009 at 12:58 PM | PERMALINK
Speaking of NPR, I can't wait to see how they play this. Morning Edition loves them some poor, unappreciated, maligned insurance companies.
Posted by: Christopher on October 22, 2009 at 1:01 PM | PERMALINK
May I suggest this website just created by Rep. Alan Grayson: Names of the Dead
It will keep track of the people who have died as a result of not being covered by insurance.
If you have a loved one or someone you know who has suffered from the heartless Insurance Companies, please register them.
Posted by: st john on October 22, 2009 at 1:06 PM | PERMALINK
OOPS! the website is: www.namesofthedead.com Still learning how to offer links.
Posted by: st john on October 22, 2009 at 1:07 PM | PERMALINK
Cool. Can I be AHIP's enemy too? Every time I hear some right-winger complaining that a public option will put private insurance companies out of business, I wonder why I'm supposed to think that's a bad thing.
Posted by: Stephen Stralka on October 22, 2009 at 1:10 PM | PERMALINK
so the american people are the enemies of the private medical insurance companies, and the environment is the enemy of the oil and energy companies, and customers are the enemies of the financial companies, and ... and ... and ...
it is so nice, when they get their backs to the wall, to hear the corporations lay out the truth amidst their squeals for more profits...
we are at war with the cannibal corporations that are destroying us.
Posted by: neill on October 22, 2009 at 1:12 PM | PERMALINK
SteinL: Where are we now? Final days of the Third Reich?
I think you mean final days of the Weimar Republic (after Germany lost World War I, when 'stabbed in the back' gained currency as an explanation for the loss).
Which would make where we are now all the more dangerous (we all know what happened next).
Note: I am not suggesting a comparison between the current administration and Hitler's regime; only that in disturbed times, dissatisfied people tend to turn truly radical.
Posted by: JCB on October 22, 2009 at 1:21 PM | PERMALINK
I'll say it again. No public option than let the reform bill die and then have the DNC run an add listing all the candidates, including pseudo-dems, that did not support the public option as obstructionists to reform.
No public option and I am calling my Senators and asking them to vote against the bill and telling them if they don't I won't be voting for them.
No public option and I am writing Obama and telling him to veto the bill or I won't be voting for him in 2012.
It is best to let the bill die rather than make the existing system more complicated and increasing profits for the unInsurance industry. Then after a few hundred thousand more people die, and a few million more go bankrupt in 3 years we'll give it another try...
Posted by: BrianInMKE on October 22, 2009 at 1:22 PM | PERMALINK
Good to know the health insurance companies have self-identified themselves with the republican party.
Now I won't lose a second of sleep when we shrink them and then drown them in the proverbial bathtub.
Assholes.
Posted by: fourlegsgood on October 22, 2009 at 1:39 PM | PERMALINK
Almost sounds like a setup for post-reform arguments:
1. I need extra bonus payments because I fought reform real hard
2. Profits are down, but don't blame me--now I need an even bigger bonus
3. I didn't want to layoff people--reform made me do it.
4. Of course reform brought us more business, but some of those people are sick--now you'll have to triple my bonus
... anything to add? (yeah, I'm feeling a little snarky today)
Posted by: golack on October 22, 2009 at 1:39 PM | PERMALINK
These bloviating asshats watch too many stupid movies. Really bad movies at that.
AHIP seems bound and determined to kill off a lot of Americans based on their company goals, actions and statements. Since they can not even perform, nor ask for a proper finanical analysis, I'm not surprised they consider those that want to live out from under their homicidal greedy boots are considered the enemy.
What an era of homicidal asshats we have these days.
Posted by: Silver Owl on October 22, 2009 at 3:00 PM | PERMALINK
Notice how he's reduced the entire thing to a question of political one-upsmanship, one which is fueled by a fairly delusional understanding of where the two parties are in the polls. But the idea that Republicans might actually want to vote on a policy issue because of, well, the policy, is irrelevant - it's only about power. He would refuse to fill a bucket with water to put out a burning house, because it would make the bucket brigade look good.
Posted by: biggerbox on October 22, 2009 at 4:05 PM | PERMALINK