October 24, 2009
THANK YOU, AHIP.... The front page of the Washington Post tells readers, "Prognosis improves for public insurance; Momentum shift is dramatic." It seems like "dramatic" is the right word, given that the public option seemed like quite a long-shot up until quite recently.
And what's behind the "momentum shift"? It seems, this week, a key turning point was Wednesday's meeting between Reid, Baucus, Dodd, and White House officials, when the leadership reportedly decided to go ahead and pursue a public option.
But let's not overlook the role of America's Health Insurance Plans (AHIP). The insurance lobby published a deceptive report on health care premiums two weeks ago, and the WaPo report today suggests it quickly changed the policy landscape.
Reid's original inclination was to leave the public option out of a final bill he is writing from measures passed by the finance and health committees. But his liberal colleagues began urging him two weeks ago to reconsider, after insurance industry forecasts that premiums would rise sharply under the Finance Committee bill, which lacked a public option. The report had the effect of prodding Democrats to look for better ways to control costs, and the public option -- strongly opposed by the insurance industry -- reemerged as a possible solution.
Because a government-run plan would be dedicated to holding down costs and would lack a profit motive, congressional budget analysts predict that it could reduce the cost of expanding coverage to people who don't have it by as much as $100 billion over the next decade.
Thank you, AHIP, for rescuing the public option.
—Steve Benen 10:15 AM
Permalink
| Trackbacks
| Comments (11)
It's dawned on the Dem leadership that they are in a position to create history, and to deliver a benefit to Americans that will be credited as transformative.
Either that, or get thrown out on their heads.
Not that hard a choice. AHIP's "report" was a desperation tactic, and fortunately was interpreted as such.
Posted by: SteinL on October 24, 2009 at 10:28 AM | PERMALINK
As we Americans begin to remember we have nothing to fear but fear itself, the political tactics of fear-mongers are being seen for what they are - attempts to sustain "highly concentrated" markets and 30+% profit margins for entrenched vested interests.
Members of our Congress vote against health care reform at their own peril! -Kevo
Posted by: kevo on October 24, 2009 at 10:35 AM | PERMALINK
I'm very happy for anything at all that makes Karen Ignagni's days less enjoyable and more frustrating. When she does it to herself that's just double frosting on the cake. Not that my health care provider would approve of course but it sure is tasty.
Posted by: burro on October 24, 2009 at 10:37 AM | PERMALINK
i am mildly amused that WaPo is forced to include such a development in its "news"...
caint you just imagine all their potential salon-dinner invitees reading this and having their spokespersons call up WaPo and scream wtf?
i am not assuming that the insurance companies are gonna give up owning medical care in this country anymore than corporate america is gonna give up gang-raping with impunity any woman any time anywhere. it's the nature of the corporation to take what it wants however it has to do so.
Posted by: neill on October 24, 2009 at 10:44 AM | PERMALINK
Can't call the public option "rescued" until it is in the final bill that passes out of both houses that the president signs. Until then, we can only say that PROSPECTS for the public option have been rescued.
It's not a small distinction. I feel better than I did last week at this time but we cannot rest yet.
Posted by: Chocolate Thunder on October 24, 2009 at 10:45 AM | PERMALINK
This would all be just fine if President "Can't We All Just Get Along?" wasn't hell-bent to have one Republican vote, that of Olympia Snowe, so he's completely willing to sell out everything for his fever-dream of "bipartisan" politics.
Posted by: TCinLA on October 24, 2009 at 11:06 AM | PERMALINK
I think the bogus AHIP "study" was helpful, but I think the WaPo is way overestimating its impact, just as they overestimated the impact of the astroturf town-hall screaming. It's always a better story to pick out some dramatic turning point, but in fact, the steady improvement in the prospects for the public option suggest that it is real grassroots pressure that is making the difference, not an inadvertant "rescue" from AHIP.
Posted by: Redshift on October 24, 2009 at 11:40 AM | PERMALINK
I hear ya, TCinLA.
Fuck Olympia Snowe and the GOP. Bipartisanship shouldn't be achieved at the public's expense.
Posted by: bdop4 on October 24, 2009 at 11:47 AM | PERMALINK
So ironic, that the President, who declared from the start that health care reform should cost nothing, prematurely declared he would sacrifice the public option, perhaps the best proposal for making reform more affordable.
And now some of the change that Obama promised in his campaign may finally get a chance on the floor of the Senate -- despite the President's earlier surrender -- thanks to the Democratic leadership, grassroots support, and AHIP.
Posted by: Chris on October 24, 2009 at 12:46 PM | PERMALINK
Poetic justice - if it prevails!
Posted by: NB on October 24, 2009 at 2:58 PM | PERMALINK
Being that they were so much against the public option their turnabout just makes me paranoid as hell. What did they discover...really...since it's all about protecting the profiteering of the ins status quo.
After being deceptive now they are supportive?? Suspicion abounds.
Posted by: bjobotts on October 24, 2009 at 5:53 PM | PERMALINK