November 7, 2009
IT'S ALWAYS SUNNY IN WEEKLY STANDARD LAND.... Jonathan Chait had a great item the other day on the defining characteristic of one of the key Republican news outlets: the Weekly Standard.
A magazine like National Review specializes in making the case for conservative ideas. The Standard's contribution is to assert over and over that Republicans are succeeding, or at least doing better than you think they are. The idea is to buck up your side and encourage them to keep fighting, in order to ward off the self-defeating psychology of losing.
It's unclear to me why the subscribers of that magazine pay money to be the subjects of a disinformation campaign. To be sure, like any stopped clock, sometimes the Standard gets it right. But there's a distinctly Pravda-esque feel to the political coverage that makes back reading an enjoyable experience.
It is a curious phenomenon. I understand the purpose of National Review, even though I find it offensive. Its writers and editors believe their ideas are the right ones, and are committed to presenting their case (a case I find deceptive, incoherent, and misguided). I can also understand the purpose of Fox News, even though I think it makes a mockery of American journalism. There's an audience for a network that will present current events through a Republican lens, and FNC caters to the niche.
But the Weekly Standard is just a cheerleader in print. Chait and Noah Kristula-Green pulled together some classic examples from recent years. Last year, for example, the magazine assured readers that John McCain was likely to win the presidency and the "new and improved" Republican brand -- which "President Bush has helped" -- would help stem congressional losses.
In 2007, the Standard said Republicans should be optimistic about the 2008 elections. In August 2006, it said the same about the midterms (you know, the cycle when Democrats re-claimed the majority in both chambers). In July 2006, the Standard assured readers that George W. Bush may be "on his way to renewed popularity."
Indeed, this morning, I swung by the Stardard's site, and the lead story was from Fred Barnes, arguing that all recent current events are "good news for Republicans -- extremely good news."
Giving Republicans a copy of the Weekly Standard is a bit like giving them a doll that says, "Everything is going to be all right" every time you squeeze it.
—Steve Benen 10:30 AM
Permalink
| Trackbacks
| Comments (10)
Corporate culture has been refining that genre for years to keep "human resources" compliant and "happy."
It is the glorious wonderful "way of life" we have here in our company -- it is the bestest.
Posted by: neill on November 7, 2009 at 10:32 AM | PERMALINK
Every Repiglicans reality is defined by absolute delusions that they need to 'believe' in order to have any chance to function. They are dependent on creating scapegoats to target in order to sustain these delusions. And when these delusions get exposed they manage to create yet more delusions in order to justify the delusion that was exposed. FOR THESE REASONS EVERY REPIGLCIAN WHEN SPEAKING SHOULD BE FORCE TO SQUEEZE A SQUEAKY TOY UNTIL THEY ARE DONE SPEAKING.
Posted by: storsmkies on November 7, 2009 at 10:44 AM | PERMALINK
The Weakly Standard is just speaking to it's readership's tendency toward fundamentalist/authoritarian thinking. It soothes them and helps them avoid all that messy ctitical analysis and questioning stuff.
Posted by: bikelib on November 7, 2009 at 10:49 AM | PERMALINK
I'd like to squeeze the WS a lot harder around the ...um...neck.
Posted by: E L on November 7, 2009 at 10:50 AM | PERMALINK
The WS has a few other functions:
Constantly screaming about the MSM being the "liberal press". That way, anytime anything is printed that doesn't favor Republicans - they can scream "SEE - liberal press! Don't listen to them, WE have the correct version."
Or, revising history in real time to make GW look good or Reagan look like the saint of the planet.
And, promoting the idea that the more money the top 0.1% of the country has, the better off everyone will be - tax cuts cure everything!
Etc.
Posted by: Mark-NC on November 7, 2009 at 10:58 AM | PERMALINK
any magazine that publishes fred barnes can't be taken seriously...
Posted by: mudwall jackson on November 7, 2009 at 1:47 PM | PERMALINK
"It's unclear to me why the subscribers of that magazine pay money to be the subjects of a disinformation campaign"
That's a good question to ask Jonathan Chait (at TNR) of his own magazine's readers. People like having their instincts, biases and racism acknowledged and legitimized with smarmy chin-scratching pseudo-intellectual justifications.
Top articles by Marty Peretz right now are "This was an act of Jihad" (about the Ft. Hood shootings), one asking, "Mr. President, "which side are you really on?", i.e., either with the democracy protesters or with the Iranian government, and "A Huge Majority of Americans Would Support Military Action Against Iran", which speaks for itself.
Posted by: flubber on November 7, 2009 at 2:51 PM | PERMALINK
The Russians will be pushed back from Berlin in a glorious victory, and our wonder weapons will allow us to go on and conquer the world!
Posted by: Der Fuhrer on November 7, 2009 at 3:08 PM | PERMALINK
just wondering: when the doll says "everything is going to be all right," does it sound like bob marley?
Posted by: dj spellchecka on November 7, 2009 at 3:50 PM | PERMALINK
Yrs ago the repub conservatives invested heavily in think tanks, propaganda PACs, news organizations and media cheerleaders. For awhile this repub propaganda bombardment seemed to work but after years of lying, misinformation and just being dead wrong on all their projections speculations and predictions their influence is waning. You just can't depend on anything they say.
The only way to not know how un-credible these groups have become (including Fox news) is to not want to know. Same with the entire repub party...the tactics of choice just aren't working any more due to the results of multiple exposures.
Posted by: bjobotts on November 7, 2009 at 4:24 PM | PERMALINK