 |
 |
Will the world's best students flock to China to study?
By Daniel Luzer
Memo: The way forward on health care reform in 2010.
By Steve Benen
How a group of Texas conservatives is rewriting your kids textbooks.
By Mariah Blake
A dark legacy of the Vietnam War is creating a whole new set of problems.
By various authors
|
|
|
|
|
November 9, 2009
IT WAS 20 YEARS AGO TODAY.... As anniversaries of major events go, the fall of the Berlin Wall -- 20 years ago today -- is right up there. Signaling the collapse of communism in Europe was a landmark moment of the 20th century.
This morning, German Chancellor Angela Merkel, labeling today a "day of celebration," thanked former USSR leader Mikhail Gorbachev: "You made this possible -- you courageously let things happen, and that was much more than we could expect." The two appeared at a big event in Berlin.
Flanked by leaders from the former Eastern Bloc in Communism's last days, and mobbed by a cheering crowd, Chancellor Angela Merkel launched a day of commemoration Monday of the fall of the Berlin Wall, retracing the steps of the first East Germans, herself included, surging to West Berlin 20 years ago.
Mrs. Merkel's symbolic walk across the Bornholmer Strasse bridge, accompanied by Mikhail S. Gorbachev, the last leader of the Soviet Union, and Lech Walesa, the former shipyard worker who led a fight against Moscow-backed Communism in Poland, came as Berlin prepared for an evening of celebration to mark the moments on Nov. 9, 1989, when the wall began to crumble.
In a light drizzle hundreds of people gathered to observe the moment, some recalling the crowds who swelled the former East German checkpoint at the Bornholmer Street crossing point after an East German official announced that, with immediate effect, travel restrictions would be eased.
Mrs. Merkel has told reporters recently that she was one of those to walk into the west that night across the gray iron bridge at Bornholmer Strasse. Many of the hundreds crowding onto the bridge with her on Monday were former East German civil rights activists.
But even now, two decades later, the sentiments within Germany are not unanimous. In the new issue of the Washington Monthly, Paul Hockenos reviews the publication of Gunter Grass' diaries, written during Germany's transformation, and intended to criticize unification and its architects, with dire predictions. Hockenos writes:
Grass's gloomy prophecies about a sinister German nationalism proved off the mark. There was never a popular appetite in 1989 or 1990 to snatch back swathes of Poland or centralize the state in the Prussian style. Postwar democracy and the processes of introspection set into motion by critically minded intellectuals like Grass (his 1959-published Tin Drum was a defining moment) had civilized German nationalism and undermined its expansionist logic. In fact, one could even argue that Germany is the model nation in coming to terms with an unsavory past. Neither Italy, Spain, nor Japan, to say nothing of the likes of Romania and Slovakia, has begun to confront its fascist collaboration the way Germany has, even if the process transpired in fits and starts, nudged along by intellectuals like Grass. Germans do wave flags now -- and no one cares. NATO allies demand they send more troops to Afghanistan's war zones, and it is the Germans who object.
Improbably, at the ripe age of eighty-two, this autumn Gunter Grass undertook another tour of eastern Germany. In the hardest hit of backwater ex-socialist towns, where crumbling housing blocks and empty storefronts still line the streets, he reads from his 1990 diaries and even does a little stumping for the Social Democrats. Still the hardheaded contrarian, he feels largely vindicated in his dark prophecies from twenty years ago. Germany may be united on paper, he argues, but resentment and income disparity still divide the nation. He sees the glass as half full, at best. Clearly, after more than five decades, Citizen Grass refuses to give Germany's powerful a free ride.
—Steve Benen 11:40 AM
Permalink
| Trackbacks
| Comments (11)
How good to have your reason and perspective in this, Steve. Thank you!
Posted by: W. Hackwhacker on November 9, 2009 at 11:55 AM | PERMALINK
I just heard Glenn Beck's stand-in on his radio program bitching and moaning about how Obama isn't in Germany today to celebrate the fall of the wall-- and he not too subtly implied that Obama doesn't think it's something to celebrate. (Because he's a commie, which is what he referred to the House's HCR bill-- as a "commie bill.")
Posted by: zoe kentucky on November 9, 2009 at 12:09 PM | PERMALINK
I am a American who has been in Germany for the past several months and I can tell you I have not heard much about Reagan today. No one is saying Reagan won the Cold War, Reagan brought the wall down, or any of the stuff we hear in the US. Reagan's name generally comes after those of Gorbachev, Walesa, Pope John Paul II, and several others. It is interesting to gain this perspective.
Posted by: Dr. U on November 9, 2009 at 12:21 PM | PERMALINK
Reunification would be like if New England and California joined Mississippi, Alabama, Arkansas etc. to form a single country. It would be a real drag on the economy and politics of the new nation.
Posted by: inkadu on November 9, 2009 at 1:21 PM | PERMALINK
The anniversary reminds me just how WRONG Reagan and the American RightWing were, ONCE AGAIN.
They kept claiming that if the wall ever came down, the people from the Eastern Bloc countries would come POURING across the borders seeking the RightWing's twisted idea of "freedom".
The reason nobody in Europe mentions Reagan is because it was all over before he ever stepped foot into the White House. By 1980, the Soviet Union's military spending was already dramatically reduced, and after Reagan was inaugurated Gorbachev informed him that the Soviet Union was unilaterally no longer an enemy of the United States of America. Unfortunately, Reagan and the American RightWing refused to take yes for an answer because it didn't jive with their agendas, and they couldn't afford to lose their Boogieman.
Posted by: Joe Friday on November 9, 2009 at 1:37 PM | PERMALINK
Forget Reagan, where's the love for David Hasselhoff?
.
Posted by: 2Manchu on November 9, 2009 at 2:23 PM | PERMALINK
Wow, feel the left wing love for East Germany...
Posted by: Amanda in the South Bay on November 9, 2009 at 3:40 PM | PERMALINK
"I am a American who has been in Germany for the past several months and I can tell you I have not heard much about Reagan today. No one is saying Reagan won the Cold War, Reagan brought the wall down, or any of the stuff we hear in the US. Reagan's name generally comes after those of Gorbachev, Walesa, Pope John Paul II, and several others. It is interesting to gain this perspective."
Well, does anybody really think Gorbatchev let the wall crumble because Reagan told him so? To ca. 90% of all Germany Reagan was a joke, a half-witted B movie actor playing the Manchurian candidate for the military-industrial complex.
And we really feared this weirdo. If he had walked a german street unguarded he wouldn't have made more than 5 meters before being torn to pieces. Literally.
That man was creepy.
"Forget Reagan, where's the love for David Hasselhoff?"
Well, back in 1990 it was enough to have the word freedom in one of your songs to have a Nr.1 hit in Europe. One of the more embarrassing parts of our recent history. But as a reminder: the Hasselfof wave (also) started in Austria before it hit Germany *g*
Posted by: Vokoban on November 9, 2009 at 3:43 PM | PERMALINK
Per Inkadu, and contra Steve, there's plenty of post-reunification regrets from former Ossis. And, outside of East Germany, a fair chunk of former communist countries entered into various forms of the crony capitalism now so central to the US and both major political parties:
http://socraticgadfly.blogspot.com/2009/11/berlin-wall-fall-20-years-on-regrets.html
Posted by: SocraticGadfly on November 9, 2009 at 4:05 PM | PERMALINK
Wow, feel the left wing love for East Germany.../i>
Huh? That doesn't even make any sense.
Better trolls, please.
Posted by: zoe kentucky on November 9, 2009 at 6:13 PM | PERMALINK
I'm still looking for that piece of The Wall I wrote my name on.
Posted by: Disputo on November 9, 2009 at 9:24 PM | PERMALINK
|
|
|