March 24, 2010
A MUDDLED REPEAL MESSAGE.... While Republican lawmakers tend to struggle in some areas (substance, honesty, integrity, seriousness of purpose, decency), they are not without strengths. As a rule, their most impressive quality is message discipline.
The GOP Powers That Be will decide what party officials and their allies are supposed to say, and Republicans tend to follow the marching orders extremely well. The GOP shapes much of the discourse simply by getting its members to all say the exact same thing, over and over again.
At the same time, however, when Republicans are struggling, it's obvious -- they start muddling their message. Take the health care "repeal" push, for example.
"We will work in every way to repeal this legislation and start over," said House Republican Conference Chairman Mike Pence, of Indiana.
Moments later, however, Pence said the House GOP was in favor of "repealing and replacing Obamacare with an approach that gives Americans more choices instead of more government."
"There are small elements of the legislation that's moving forward that Republicans have always supported," he said.
Got that? The whole package has to go -- except for those good parts. Which provisions of the new law do Republicans like and plan to keep? They'll have to get back to us on that.
Sen. Jim DeMint (R-S.C.) wants to repeal the whole thing, but Senate Minority Leader Mitch McConnell (R-Ky.) is only interested in repealing the "egregious parts." Reps. Michelle Bachmann (R-Minn.) and Steve King (R-Iowa) demand a full repeal, while National Republican Senatorial Committee Chairman John Cornyn (R-Tex.) wants to leave the "non-controversial stuff" alone.
Mitt Romney wants to scrap the whole package, while Rep. Brett Guthrie (R-Ky.) declared, "We always said there are things that we can all agree on in the bill."
Rep. Phil Gringrey (R-Ga.) "does not want" to repeal the whole thing, and Sens. Jon Kyl (R-Ariz.) and Mike Enzi (R-Wyo.) see partial repeal as more realistic than the full repeal some of their GOP colleagues are pushing.
Republicans, in other words, are already finding themselves stuck in the repeal trap we've been talking about for months. Party leaders continue to characterize the new law as "Armageddon," but are grudgingly coming to believe some parts of Armageddon may not be that bad after all.
Democrats are not only thrilled, they're seizing on Republicans' discomfort. The DSCC has even set up a "new feature designed to make it easier to track who's called for repeal and who hasn't."
It took a while, but the trap has been set. Republicans can either infuriate their base (which has been misled about health care from the start), or they can alienate the mainstream electorate.
—Steve Benen 9:30 AM
Permalink
| Trackbacks
| Comments (30)
Rock, I'd like you to meet hard place.
Posted by: MattF on March 24, 2010 at 9:34 AM | PERMALINK
It would be great if these guys were consistently asked how it is they plan to achieve repeal when the man who just sheperded the bill to his desk for signing is still the President. Seems like an obvious flaw in their plans.
Posted by: brent on March 24, 2010 at 9:35 AM | PERMALINK
We are witnessing the fracturing of the GOP...way to stay on message- obviously they only stay on message with boilerplate topics. The bill isn't perfect, but it's something to build on.
Posted by: johnnymags on March 24, 2010 at 9:37 AM | PERMALINK
Seems to me they are going for the twofer alienating everyone while we laugh.
Posted by: Dave on March 24, 2010 at 9:38 AM | PERMALINK
Just to add to the muddle, I got an email from Jim DeMint with this link:
http://repealitpledge.com/obamacare?c=ZULOP
Posted by: martin on March 24, 2010 at 9:41 AM | PERMALINK
Rest assured, by November they'll be campaigning in their districts taking credit for passing it.
"or they can alienate the mainstream electorate"
The real issue is whether or not the mainstream electorate shows up to vote.
Posted by: SaintZak on March 24, 2010 at 9:41 AM | PERMALINK
The attorney general in Washington States wants to sue the government over the mandates. His quest hit a major bump yesterday...the governor Christione Gregoire. The woman is fierce. She clearly explains why she is against this action by the attorney general. This is a must see video.
http://www.dailykos.com/storyonly/2010/3/23/849866/-WA-Gov-Slams-AG-Over-HCR-Suit-(UPDATE)
Posted by: Ladyhawke on March 24, 2010 at 9:45 AM | PERMALINK
Here's what I don't understand: If this is going to be "Armageddon," then why don't they just wait until they're all "taken to the Lord," and then they won't have to worry about the rest of us heathens that are "left behind?"
Posted by: cr on March 24, 2010 at 9:45 AM | PERMALINK
brent,
After winning a 26 seat landslide in the senate and winning the house, they are going to impeach Obama and Biden for...something, and then president Boner will sign the repeal bill to great fanfare. And all the tea baggers will live happily after. And everyone gets a pony that they get to keep after the rapture and ride in heaven.
Posted by: the seal on March 24, 2010 at 9:46 AM | PERMALINK
Dear Rep. Pence:
I am pleased to say that for once, I agree with your goal as stated, to "give Americans more choices." It is even easier, however, to achieve this than you think. There is no need to repeal President Obama's recent reform package. All you need to do is pass a simple, straightforward bill creating a public option to compete against private plans in the market-based exchanges. Just like that, all Americans will have another, significant choice. You will have accomplished your goal! Easy, huh?
Hope this has been helpful.
Yours in health and good governance,
- Zeitgeist"
Posted by: zeitgeist on March 24, 2010 at 9:53 AM | PERMALINK
Meh, though it's fun to point out the hypocrisy, they won't be held accountable. SOP for politicians everywhere. It works in other direction too. Obama's basking in the glory of the Most Awesomeist Bill Evah, but he did campaign on a Public Option and even dissed the Mandate. Anyone care (anyone with a megaphone, I mean)?
Posted by: ed on March 24, 2010 at 9:54 AM | PERMALINK
Kinda wonder which RepuG staffer started tapping them on their collective shoulders and told them this bill is essentially the one the Heritage Foundation introduced as the RepuG plan in '93? They are becoming as dumb as those Tea Baggers who want government out of their Medicare. Or the Militia nut in Alabama who wants government out of his SSI checks.
Posted by: berttheclock on March 24, 2010 at 9:55 AM | PERMALINK
"and everyone gets a pony"
Only, if said ponies are Kentucky breds and Mitch gets the kickback.
Posted by: berttheclock on March 24, 2010 at 9:57 AM | PERMALINK
Yesterday, I laughed at crusty old Pat Buchanan backpedaling on the repeal efforts, insisting that "Repeal and Reform" was the GOP's answer to passage of healthcare reform. I have no doubt that what he meant was, "Repeal and Regress," especially when it comes to women's and minorities' issues.
Posted by: Carol A on March 24, 2010 at 9:59 AM | PERMALINK
The GOP is a big tent and it's not surprising that there should be a diversity of viewpoints.
Posted by: Al on March 24, 2010 at 10:09 AM | PERMALINK
You repeal what you sow.
Simple.
Oops, I mean you sow what you wish you repealed.
Oh never mind.....
Posted by: Tom Nicholson on March 24, 2010 at 10:14 AM | PERMALINK
Al said:
The GOP is a big tent and it's not surprising that there should be a diversity of viewpoints.
Not to mention a diverse set of realities that the Republicans, with their various psychoses, perceive.
Posted by: SteveT on March 24, 2010 at 10:15 AM | PERMALINK
Hey Seal...
"And everyone gets a pony that they get to keep after the rapture and ride in heaven."
Actually, EVERYONE knows that they, as Jesus did while here on Earth; everyone knows that they will be riding dinosaurs in heaven!
Posted by: Ralph Kramden on March 24, 2010 at 10:38 AM | PERMALINK
The repubs are being devious. If the Dems spend all their campaign money blasting repubs for stonewalling HCR, they won't have any money left to blast repubs for stonewalling banking reform.
Posted by: Tim H on March 24, 2010 at 10:53 AM | PERMALINK
Class act statergy..never changes , just change the subject.Underpants Gnomes of public policy.
1. Repeal Health-care Bill
2. ???????????
3. Win Presidential election 2 years early
Posted by: john R on March 24, 2010 at 11:05 AM | PERMALINK
It seems to me the healthcare companies hear this talk and get behind the Democrats, who will preserve the necessary, subsidized mandate that Republicans want to eliminate.
Posted by: bob h on March 24, 2010 at 11:06 AM | PERMALINK
Republicans: racist, passive/aggressive thugs.
Posted by: andyvillager on March 24, 2010 at 11:20 AM | PERMALINK
"We will work in every way to repeal this legislation and start over," said House Republican Conference Chairman Mike Pence, of Indiana.
Did he say this during that press conference where all of two journalists showed up?
As for the repeal... I'm sure they'll try to chip away at the edges, same as they are doing with Roe vs Wade. Like with Roe, trying to repeal the whole thing would be both impossible and unproductive, politically but nibbling at the edges shows that they're serious of intent and keeps the issue in the public eye, serving as a good fundraising pitch.
Posted by: exlibra on March 24, 2010 at 11:28 AM | PERMALINK
The problem, Steve, is that they haven't seen enough polling yet to know whether full repeal or partial repeal is more popular with the voters they intend to scare into voting for them.
Posted by: and on March 24, 2010 at 12:21 PM | PERMALINK
There are two problems for the Republicans. First, many of the details of the health care bill are pretty popular. Now that the bill has passed even NPR is running pieces on those details. The people I am talking to are already tickled with some of the changes. The poll numbers are changing now that the focus is on policy and not process. Fox News is still hung up on process, but their watchers are the 30% who don't want to know the truth.
Second, none of the Democrats are saying that this is the final bill or that changes and improvements don't need to be made. If the Republicans come up with some change or other, they might be surprised when Democrats run to the front with improvement bills of their own.
For Republicans the health care bill is toxic. Neither the Repeal it outright or the keep the good and change the bad approaches really help them or hurt the Democrats.
The key issue for the fall election would seem to be the economy. There are glimmers of improvements on that front. Republicans need to start praying for a double dip recession.
By the way, isn't it odd that the Boomers came in with Vietnam protests back in the 60s and are now going out kicking and screaming. I wonder if they are the same people marching now that marched then? Nah, but there is something about the Boomer Generation.
Posted by: Ron Byers on March 24, 2010 at 12:24 PM | PERMALINK
IT'S NOT THAT REPUBLICANS ARTE GOOD AT MESSAGING...IT'S THAT THEY OWN THE MESSAGING MACHINE...THE HUGE MEGAPHONE THAT SCREAMS THEIR RHETORIC.
If not for the internet giving us the ability to fact check, ALL we would hear would be republican propaganda.
The rhetoric of republicans is ridiculous saying nothing of value but always condescending and insulting. (and NO, both sides don't both do it).
Posted by: bjobotts on March 24, 2010 at 12:36 PM | PERMALINK
Let's assume, for the sake of argument, that there are actually some Republicans in Congress who don't disagree with all the provisions of the Health reform bill (sightings have been reported). Unfortunately, after nine months of inciting "the mob" they are now in a position where they can't say anything about the bill without alienating the very group of voters they riled up.
In effect, it's a poker game, in which the Republicans have gone all in with a busted hand, and the Democrats have a full House (and Senate).
I doubt at this point that any compromise is possible between the Democrats and the Republicans in this political climate. If the GOP is unwilling to do the job they were hired to do, let's make sure the public knows about it.
Posted by: rwgate on March 24, 2010 at 3:29 PM | PERMALINK
Various Republicans have already said in the last few months that they agree with 80% of what was in the reform package... but they wanted to start over from scratch. That didn't make any sense then, and now it doesn't make any sense to repeal something when you agree with 80% of it.
These people really are from a different planet.
Posted by: josef on March 24, 2010 at 3:43 PM | PERMALINK
"Now that the bill has passed even NPR is running pieces on those details."
Why the fuck weren't they--and other media outlets--running those pieces before? The Democrat's messaging has been weak throughout the process, but the media should have provided details on the bill's content before the voting started.
Posted by: croatoan on March 24, 2010 at 4:36 PM | PERMALINK
I wonder if you would be willing to review my web site? I've an identical blog and I usually ask webmasters who blog about the same stuff to exchange reviews. This is crucial for getting new visitors to yr site and to mine as well ;D
Posted by: big bang theory episodes on January 15, 2011 at 9:16 AM | PERMALINK