Editore"s Note
Tilting at Windmills

Email Newsletter icon, E-mail Newsletter icon, Email List icon, E-mail List icon Sign up for Free News & Updates

September 5, 2010

IT'S A CONTEST OF ONE EXTREME, NOT TWO.... David Broder's column today reports from Pennsylvania, home to a tough Senate race pitting Rep. Joe Sestak, who defeated Sen. Arlen Specter in a Democratic primary this year, against former Rep. Pat Toomey (R). Broder, as is his wont, wants the candidates to be centrists.

...Toomey and Sestak are squaring off for a showdown that presents the clearest of choices but leaves thousands of independent-minded voters wondering where to go. [...]

Sestak and Toomey are on opposite sides on most big issues. Sestak campaigned against the war in Iraq; supported Hillary Clinton for the 2008 Democratic presidential nomination; voted with President Obama on the stimulus bill, health care and the cap-and-trade energy bill; and has perfect voting score from the abortion-rights group NARAL Pro-Choice America.

Toomey argues for extending all the Bush tax cuts; opposes the three main Obama initiatives; is pro-life and against gay marriage; and wants to eliminate the estate tax and reduce several business levies. He has a lifetime approval rating of 97 percent from the American Conservative Union.

Pennsylvanians, Broder concludes, can expect "two months of ads arguing that the other guy is the extremist." Perhaps. Call me old fashioned, but I think it matters whether one, both, or neither are correct when making the allegation.

To hear Broder tell it, Sestak, a decorated Navy veteran, is a liberal, while Toomey, a veteran of Wall Street and the right-wing Club for Growth, is a conservative. For those in "the middle" who don't consider themselves ideologues, the two candidates are appealing exclusively to the party bases.

But that's a deeply flawed look at these candidates. Toomey, for example, is extremely conservative. One recent statistical analysis found that Toomey, based on his voting record, is "considerably" more conservative than Rick Santorum was during his tenure, and had a record in Congress more ideologically in tune with notorious North Carolinian Jesse Helms. One of the more important issues in the campaign is Toomey's desire to privatize Social Security, an idea that isn't exactly mainstream.

Is Sestak the mirror image, as liberal as Toomey is conservative? Not even close. According to the VoteView scores, Sestak's voting record puts him about in the middle of the House Democratic caucus. There's a House Progressive Caucus for the chamber's most liberal lawmakers, and Sestak isn't a member. On the campaign trail recently, Sestak has boasted of his endorsements, not from liberal Dems, but from NYC's independent mayor, Michael Bloomberg, and former Republican Sen. Chuck Hagel of Nebraska.

"Independent-minded voters" are left "wondering where to go"? This is a race that leaves "the middle" feeling left out?

I find this line of analysis deeply odd. Given Broder's general inclinations, it seems he should be going out of his way to praise Sestak for running a mainstream campaign in a diverse state against a knee-jerk ideologue. Instead, Broder is more inclined to put a pox on both houses, when only one deserves it.

Steve Benen 8:40 AM Permalink | Trackbacks | Comments (14)

Bookmark and Share
 
Comments

I was part of a Delaware County Wage Peace & Justice protest that confronted Sestak over his stand on the Iraq War a few years ago. I appreciated the fact that he spoke with us directly before we began our march to his office, but I didn't agree with his rationale for voting for more money for the Iraq War (His explanation was that he wanted to arrange for an orderly withdrawal and not a panicked flight).
No, you're absolutely right. Sestak is by no means a hard-core liberal.

Posted by: Rich2506 on September 5, 2010 at 8:56 AM | PERMALINK

You do realize, Rich, that to the extent Sestak gets identified with YOU -- he loses.

Posted by: theAmericanist on September 5, 2010 at 9:12 AM | PERMALINK

Steve,

We're talking about Dave Broder here. You didn't really expect him to acknowledge that a Democrat is a centrist while his Republican opponent is an extremist, did you? I don't know how Broder ever got a reputation as being some sort of dean of the pundits because ever since I've starting reading him back when WaPo was just starting its slide into oblivion, the man has been a raving idiot. The man is a right wing flack whether he acknowledges it or not, and apparently has been one since at least the Nixon administration according to what I've read of his history.

Posted by: Texas Aggie on September 5, 2010 at 9:21 AM | PERMALINK

Broderism is the theory that the metaphysical center is found by pitting Evan Bayh against Jim DeMint.

Posted by: walt on September 5, 2010 at 9:28 AM | PERMALINK

Is the Dean back from his Pageant of the Tenantry on Beaver Island? I mean his annual vacation to the family compound overlooking Lake Michigan, that he writes about this time of year--his encounter with Real Americans.
I'd like to see him do a Man Who Comes To Dinner in East Grand Rapids instead; to get stranded in his former home town and spend some time watching actual local news or reading a newspaper in which the Chevy ads outnumber the Lexi. He can see that moderation in action: Democrats acting like Democrats and Republicans acting like lunatics.
The joke here in Michigan is that the two reactionaries running for Gov on the GOP ticket canceled each other out: Mad Pete Hoekstra and AG Mike "Can't Keep His" Cox "In His Pants" (he had to acknowledge an extramarital affair that lasted TEN YEARS) did such Bob Forehead dives to the bottom to appease the Tea Party that a mild-mannered computer tycoon walked right by them to the Gov nom.
Now the TP's can't get past the idea that they might have to vote for someone without foam around his mouth

Posted by: Steve Paradis on September 5, 2010 at 9:31 AM | PERMALINK

Sounds like Broder just reached into his jar of cookie-cutters and whipped out another Broderism column. The guy seems to do his best work with Play-doh.

Posted by: GP on September 5, 2010 at 9:36 AM | PERMALINK

Broder has been phoning it in for some time, and because he's gotten more lazy and one-note, he's a classic Overton Window victim. Split the difference and call yourself Solomon.

Besides, as any REGULAR attendee at the BETTER Georgetown dinner tables knows, there really is only ONE governing class, and of COURSE it has its finger on the Real Center of American Politics. I mean, who else could possibly be wise enough?

Posted by: bleh on September 5, 2010 at 9:43 AM | PERMALINK

Finding the pony in the pile of shit, I can only say that an ever- dwindling portion of the populace watch/read what passes for "journalism' these days.

As evidence, I was recently at an event, and did some off the cuff poling. Few of these Average Americans knew who Glen Beck was, and didn't remember who ran against Obama two years ago.

Let's not all move to Sweden just yet. . .

Posted by: DAY on September 5, 2010 at 10:33 AM | PERMALINK

input this URL:
( http://www.fashiongoods.us )
you can find many cheap and fashion stuff
(jor dan s-h-o-e-s)
(NBA NFL NHL MLB j-e-r-s-e-y)
( lv h-a-n-d-b-a-g)
(cha nel w-a-l-l-e-t)
(D&G s-u-n-g-l-a-s-s-e-s)
(ed har dy j-a-c-k-e-t)
(UG G b-o-o-t)

WE ACCEPT PYAPAL PAYMENT
YOU MUST NOT MISS IT!!!

Posted by: gaga94 on September 5, 2010 at 11:45 AM | PERMALINK

High Broderism, otherwise known as journalistic laziness. His position has been a sinecure for decades now, at least.

Posted by: digitusmedius on September 5, 2010 at 4:22 PM | PERMALINK

The near-certainty that, come next year, PA's Junior Senator will be Pat Toomey + its Governor will be Tom Corbett is nearly enough to convince me to move to Joisey.

P'tooey,
-Z

Posted by: Zorro on September 5, 2010 at 4:36 PM | PERMALINK

Agree with gaga94, Broder is journalistically lazy. Must keep dinging these guys like George Will, Krauthammer, Broder, et al., who attempt to legitimize lies and innuendo with intelligence.

By David S. Broder
Thursday, February 11, 2010
....Take Sarah Palin seriously.

.... showed off a public figure at the top of her game -- a politician who knows who she is and how to sell herself, even with notes on her palm.

This was not the first time that Palin has impressed me. I gave her high marks for her vice presidential acceptance speech in St. Paul. But then, and always throughout that campaign, she was laboring to do more than establish her own place. She was selling a ticket headed by John McCain against formidable Democratic opposition and burdened by the legacy of the Bush administration.

... to display the full repertoire she possesses, touching on national security, economics, fiscal and social policy, and every other area where she could draw a contrast with Barack Obama ...

Freed of the responsibilities she carried as governor of Alaska [ain't that convenient?], devoid of any official title but armed with regular gigs on Fox News Channel and more speaking invitations than she can fulfill [$$$], Palin is perhaps the most visible Republican in the land. [Your point being...?]

Posted by: losamigos on September 5, 2010 at 8:21 PM | PERMALINK

broder's mythical center is so far right that an actual centrist like sestak looks like an extremist to him...

Posted by: dj spellchecka on September 5, 2010 at 11:28 PM | PERMALINK

David Broder has been a willing Republican stooge since at least 1962, when he wrote articles favoring Nixon for Governor of California. Not one of his columns of "advice" going back to 1969 has ever been accurate, and all can be defined as "Democrats are going to be in trouble unless they adopt Republican policies and grant that the Republicans are the ones who really know what is what."

Broder is a moron and the sooner the senile old fool goes where senile old fools eventually end up, the better.

Posted by: TCinLA on September 6, 2010 at 2:18 AM | PERMALINK




 

 

Read Jonathan Rowe remembrance and articles
Email Newsletter icon, E-mail Newsletter icon, Email List icon, E-mail List icon Sign up for Free News & Updates

Advertise in WM



buy from Amazon and
support the Monthly


Place Your Link Here

--- Links ---

Boarding Schools

Addiction Treatment Centers

Alcohol Treatment Center

Bad Credit Loan

Long Distance Moving Companies

FREE Phone Card

Flowers

Personal Loan

Addiction Treatment

Phone Cards

Less Debt = Financial Freedom

Addiction Treatment Programs