U.S. CHAMBER OF COMMERCE AND THE GOP, SITTIN' IN A TREE.... The U.S. Chamber of Commerce is spending tens of millions of dollars to buy midterm elections for far-right Republican candidates. As if that weren't enough, the business lobby is using undisclosed contributions. And as if that weren't enough, some of the financing for these ads may have come from foreign corporations and foreign governments.
But just to add insult to injury, the Chamber's pro-GOP ads also happen to mislead the public. Greg Sargent had this report today on the Chamber's ads targeting House Democrats:
These Chamber ads, which are running or have run in multiple districts across the country, contain many claims that are demonstrable distortions or have been repeatedly debunked as false by independent fact-checkers.
This is the side of this story that continues to unfold under the media radar. Much of the media focus has been on the high-profile Beltway spat between these groups and the White House and Dems over their undisclosed donors. But the ads themselves are not receiving anywhere near the high-profile media scrutiny that Dem claims about the Chamber have -- even though they constitute a massive national campaign flooding airwaves in multiple races that could tip the balance of power in Congress.
Greg's analysis is worth checking out in full, because the demonstrably-false claims featured in the Chamber's ads -- including some arguments that were debunked months ago -- are the same claims that may very well mislead voters and sway election outcomes.
What's also interesting, though, was the Chamber's response to the fact-checking. The business lobby put together a fairly detailed rebuttal, which Greg also posted.
But as rebuttals go, the Chamber of Commerce's retort seems to create as many problems as it resolves. Not only does it rehash tired and misguided Republican talking points, but it relies heavily on a report commissioned by House Republicans.
In other words, the Chamber (a) is airing misleading attack ads in order to help Republicans; and (b) relying on Republicans to defend themselves against evidence that the attacks are misleading.
The Chamber is effectively arguing, "See? The ads we're airing on behalf of Republicans are accurate -- because Republicans say so."
The thinly-veiled pretense of the U.S. Chamber of Commerce being "independent" and "non-partisan" has all but disappeared.
—Steve Benen 4:15 PM
Permalink
| Trackbacks
| Comments (7)
The GOP's tenuous grip on logic seems to be based upon the following statement:
"A supposition based on a supposition cannot be refuted".
For instance, "God made the moon, therefore God exists".
Or, "Republicans have never increased the deficit, therefore Republicans are fiscal conservatives". Bwah hah hah! And if you believe that, I can get you a great deal on the Brooklyn Bridge.
Posted by: Kiweagle on October 18, 2010 at 6:03 PM | PERMALINK
Not only does it rehash tired and misguided Republican talking points, but it relies heavily on a report commissioned by House Republicans.
Not only does it rely on a report commissioned by House Republicans, that report was on the House version of the bill in November 2009, which was abandoned in order to pass the Senate version in December 2009, followed by the "fixes" to the bill passed in March 2010. Any resemblance between the Chamber's cited report and the actual bill is absolutely coincidental.
Posted by: Daddy Love on October 18, 2010 at 6:41 PM | PERMALINK