College Guide
Blog
In the list of potentially troublesome ethical issues in academia, selling grades ranks pretty high. That’s why it’s usually done secretly. Not if you’re Bernard Gibson, professor of business, marketing, management, and diversity at Folsom Lake College.
According to an article by Laurel Rosenhall and Melody Gutierrez in the Sacramento Bee:
And at Folsom Lake College last week, a professor offered to increase students’ grades if they raised money for the college foundation. He rescinded the offer Monday after students and other faculty raised concerns.
A video of his lecture last Thursday shows Gibson presenting the deal to his marketing class: “If you raise $25 you can get enough extra credit to take you from a C- minus to a C. It can’t take you to a B but it could move you within the range of a grade. “If you raise $50 or more … you can receive enough extra credit to move you from a C-minus to a B-minus. It actually can move you into the next grade category.”
Oh, no, it’s not selling grades, protests Gibson; he’s just offering an incentive (“extra-credit related to a lesson on fundraising,” according to the article). While the details of this little transaction are unclear (does just writing a check count as fundraising, or do other people have to contribute in order for the grade improvement to happen?) something about this incentive seems a little odd.
If someone’s earning a C minus in a marketing class isn’t his time better spent studying harder than working on some college fundraiser?
Gibson has canceled the extra-credit plan.
Facebook
Twitter
MNP on April 11, 2011 6:29 PM:
I disagree. If someone is earning a C-minus in his marketing class but in the real world can actually market for real money, then clearly the class material is not reflecting the ability of the actual student.
We can quibble about how much money should equal a grade level--I'd say assign a monetary value by taking the grade points of the class (1-4) and dividing by the cost of the class--but I think the idea is a good one.
BRB on April 11, 2011 8:45 PM:
You should watch the video, there's no marketing required. Just cool, hard cash. http://professorellerman.blogspot.com/2011/04/grades-for-sale.html