College Guide
Blog
Southern Illinois University, like many state colleges, occasionally offers full merit scholarships to students. The merit scholarships, which are state funded, offer free tuition to high-achieving students.
Among education advocates they’re controversial, but they’re a common feature of higher education and an admissions race to attract the best students.
But it’s a little awkward when the merit scholarship goes to the granddaughter of the college president, no matter how accomplished she may be. According to an article an article by Jodi Cohen in the Chicago Tribune
Maddie Poshard is a stellar student, with excellent grades, a top ACT score, and a history of exemplary leadership at her Springfield area high school. She is just the kind of student Southern Illinois University wants for its Presidential/Chancellor Scholarships, a taxpayer-funded free ride for four years worth about $80,000.
The problem is that the president, whose title is referenced in the scholarship, is her grandfather, Glenn Poshard. According to the article:
“That’s a tough question. It’s a tricky one. It’s a hard call,” said Dan Mann, director of student financial aid at the University of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign. “I would think (Poshard) would say, ‘This isn’t appropriate for you to get the scholarship and you shouldn’t be considered.’”
Is it really a tough question, though?
This is the problem with merit scholarships, after all. They tend not to go to financially needy students. In general the point of offering such scholarships, from the school’s perspective, is to encourage students who might otherwise attend more selective universities, to go to your own less prestigious one; such students improve the quality of the school. In this case, however, it not only seems to be a public relations problem. Why did the school think this was one of the best people to award full tuition?
While her grandfather maintains that he thinks the scholarship decision is appropriate— “If she is unqualified that is one thing. But she is not unqualified. I’m not trying to get any special favors for my granddaughter and she didn’t get any,” he told the Tribune—it hardly seems like the best use of public money.
It seems that everyone would have been better off if she’d just decided to go elsewhere. Her grandfather, a former congressman, makes $320,000 a year. Her family could probably well afford tuition at some other school.
Facebook
Twitter
Chief on June 29, 2011 12:30 AM:
While I have not known many politicians, I do know that generally they do not have a very good reputation.
However, I did live for 18 years in southern Illinois and did attend SIU. I also was a volunteer on several of Mr. Poshards congressional and gubernatorial campaigns.
Mr Poshard is as honest and upright as any person that I've ever met. While it may look bad with him being the president of SIU, I can't understand how punishing an exceptional student brings any fairness to the situation. It is certainly not her fault what her grandfather does.
If Mr. Poshard was a serial murderer or a terrorist, would you use those grounds to deny her a full merit scholarship?
Texas Aggie on June 29, 2011 10:13 AM:
The more important point is that her family would have no problem at all paying full tuition. She may "deserve" the scholarship based on her performance, but scholarships are instituted to help deserving people who otherwise would lose an opportunity at higher education. It would make a lot more sense to give the scholarship to someone just as accomplished who actually needed the money.
David Chisholm on June 29, 2011 2:09 PM:
This is an easy call. Mr. Poshard should fund another one time scholarship amounting to his granddaughters award. He could make the point that while his granddaughter certainly deserves the award based upon her performance, for which he is justly proud, he is personally funding an additional scholarship in his granddaughters name to celebrate her accomplishments.
David Chisholm