On Political Books

November/ December 2011 Justice Served

U.S. Supreme Court Justice John Paul Stevens's thirty-five-year tenure was marked by intellectual rigor, lack of pretension, and the firm belief that absolutism had no place on the bench.

By Michael O'Donnell

And therein lies Stevens’s tremendous appeal as a judge—regardless of whether one agrees with all of his decisions. He was an absolutist about nothing. Absolute positions on the law—be they on the subject of free speech or the framers’ intent—often require the judge to set down reason and common sense so that he can hold a banner with both hands. It is therefore unsurprising that the one justice about whom Stevens has no kind words in Five Chiefs is Clarence Thomas, who is more rigid in his vision of the Constitution than perhaps any justice in the Court’s history. If the Tea Party has taught us anything, it is that the absolutists will shout past each other until the whole damn operation grinds to a halt. Without Stevens, the Supreme Court is that much more likely to do the same thing.

If you are interested in purchasing this book, we have included a link for your convenience.

Michael O'Donnell , a frequent contributor to the Washington Monthly, is a lawyer living in Chicago with his family.


  • Dewey evana on October 05, 2012 7:16 PM:

    my name is Dewey Evans
    I want to tell a story
    the story pertains a lot of old people
    I am interested
    and I have got ripped off from a company called David and associates
    they call themselves Davidson and design is also out of Pittsburgh Pennsylvania
    I was taking for 18,000 dollars
    and 2 years later Pennsylvania decides to file charges on
    because a woman turned into a nother complaints
    similar to mine
    little did they know it was 500 the case
    just like mine
    is it possible that you can call me or contact me to put this in your magazine it would be such a great help for the United States Justice Department to look and see what is going on
    we are just little people what we need help alsot this to the mail and also do telephone and
    call 713 256 3867
    I believe it's mafia control