Ten Miles Square

Blog

February 15, 2012 8:00 AM Zombie Politics: The Voting Behavior of White Working Class

By John Sides

Zombie politics—a play on Zombie Economics—refers to ideas about politics that have become so cemented in conventional wisdom that it is virtually impossible to dislodge them.  It doesn’t matter what the data says, or what published research says, or what this blog or any blog says.  Zombie politics means that even though the ideas are dead, they just can’t be killed.  I regret using the by-now-hackneyed zombie metaphor, but it remains apt.

And so, George Packer:

Perhaps the biggest political puzzle of our time is why, as the lives of working-class whites have descended from the stability and comfort of “All in the Family” to the chaos and despair of “Gran Torino” and “Winter’s Bone,” these same Americans have voted more and more reliably Republican.

This would be a puzzle, if it were really true.  From Larry Bartels:

The graph indicates only the merest hint of a secular trend in the voting behavior of whites without college degrees.  It also shows that there is not much of a difference between the behavior of whites with and without college degrees since about 1980.  Now, one could still argue that the white working class should vote more Democratic given their ostensible class interests.  But they have not become “more and more reliably Republican.”

If one takes account not only of educational attainment but also income, the picture is even less kind to the zombie:

Among whites without a college degree, income has become a stronger predictor of the vote over time.  But actually it’s those with less income, not more income, who are more likely to support Democratic presidential candidates.  And again, there certainly no trend by which whites with below-average incomes and no college degree become more Republican.

The real decline in white working class support for Democrats occurs in the South.  Bartels:


Democratic presidential vote share has declined by almost 20 percentage points among southern whites without college degrees. Among non-southern whites without college degrees it has declined by one percentage point. That’s it. Fourteen elections, 52 years, one percentage point.

Packer’s post only glimpses this reality, describing this hypothetical white working-class man:


…he lost his idealism and grew surly, if not violent, consumed with a hatred of hippies, immigrants, blacks, government, and, finally, himself.


And in noting that the story has at least something to with region and with the South in particular:


Sunday’s Times had a fascinating and disturbing lead story about the pattern of government dependency around the country. A map showing areas of greatest reliance on public benefits corresponds with weird exactness to the map of red America: the South, Appalachia, and rural areas in general.


But in light of Bartels’s findings, the “exactness” is hardly “weird.”  It suggests that we are talking about a phenomenon confined to a region rather than one that describes the white working class at large.

For emphasis, one more stab at the zombie: The white working class has not, as a whole, become more Republican.  Full stop.

[Cross-posted at The Monkey Cage]

Back to Home page

John Sides is an associate professor of political science at George Washington University.

Comments

  • Chase on February 23, 2012 9:20 AM:

    I have many, many friends in my small town and none of them have ever or will ever vote Republican.

    I live in the deep south for crying out loud!

    The Republican party is a dying breed.

  • CDW on February 26, 2012 12:46 PM:

    The studies you cite, or at least the graphs you show deal only with presidential politics. What might be more telling are local and state politics where, it seems to me, conservatives have consistently made gains and where the tilt of the voters is most telling.